Re: nodes are always out of sync

2017-04-02 Thread benjamin roth
Btw.: I created an issue for that some months ago https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CASSANDRA-12991 2017-04-01 22:25 GMT+02:00 Roland Otta : > thank you both chris and benjamin for taking time to clarify that. > > > On Sat, 2017-04-01 at 21:17 +0200, benjamin roth wrote: > > Tl;Dr: there are

Re: nodes are always out of sync

2017-04-01 Thread Roland Otta
thank you both chris and benjamin for taking time to clarify that. On Sat, 2017-04-01 at 21:17 +0200, benjamin roth wrote: Tl;Dr: there are race conditions in a repair and it is not trivial to fix them. So we rather stay with these race conditions. Actually they don't really hurt. The worst cas

Re: nodes are always out of sync

2017-04-01 Thread benjamin roth
Tl;Dr: there are race conditions in a repair and it is not trivial to fix them. So we rather stay with these race conditions. Actually they don't really hurt. The worst case is that ranges are repaired that don't really need a repair. Am 01.04.2017 21:14 schrieb "Chris Lohfink" : > Repairs do not

Re: nodes are always out of sync

2017-04-01 Thread benjamin roth
I think your way to communicate needs work. No one forces you to answer on questions. Am 01.04.2017 21:09 schrieb "daemeon reiydelle" : > What you are doing is correctly going to result in this, IF there is > substantial backlog/network/disk or whatever pressure. > > What do you think will happen

Re: nodes are always out of sync

2017-04-01 Thread Chris Lohfink
Repairs do not have an ability to instantly build a perfect view of its data between your 3 nodes at an exact time. When a piece of data is written there is a delay between when they applied between the nodes, even if its just 500ms. So if a request to read the data and build the merkle tree of the

Re: nodes are always out of sync

2017-04-01 Thread daemeon reiydelle
What you are doing is correctly going to result in this, IF there is substantial backlog/network/disk or whatever pressure. What do you think will happen when you write with a replication factor greater than consistency level of write? Perhaps your mental model of how C* works needs work? *.

Re: nodes are always out of sync

2017-04-01 Thread Vladimir Yudovin
Hi, did you try to read data with consistency ALL immediately after write with consistency ONE? Does it succeed? Best regards, Vladimir Yudovin, Winguzone - Cloud Cassandra Hosting On Thu, 30 Mar 2017 04:22:28 -0400 Roland Otta wrote hi,

nodes are always out of sync

2017-03-30 Thread Roland Otta
hi, we see the following behaviour in our environment: cluster consists of 6 nodes (cassandra version 3.0.7). keyspace has a replication factor 3. clients are writing data to the keyspace with consistency one. we are doing parallel, incremental repairs with cassandra reaper. even if a repair ju