Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-25 Thread Tommy Stendahl
I have finally tracked down the problem and I'm happy to say that this is not a Cassandra problem. I found out that we have a custom security provider installed on our servers and when I disabled that the problem disappeared. /Tommy On 2018-01-19 14:40, Tommy Stendahl wrote: I have continu

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-19 Thread Tommy Stendahl
I have continued the upgrade of the cluster using the default protocol setting and after upgrading all nodes there were no problems switching back to "TLSv1.2". But I will try to reproduce the problem using a ccm cluster, I think that should be relatively easy, and when  can try the -Djavax.net

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-17 Thread Nate McCall
> > We use Oracle jdk1.8.0_152 on all nodes and as I understand oracle use a > dot in the protocol name (TLSv1.2) and I use the same protocol name and > cipher names in the 3.0.14 nodes and the one I try to upgrade to 3.11.1. > I agree with Stefan's assessment and share his confusion. Would you be

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-17 Thread Tommy Stendahl
We use Oracle jdk1.8.0_152 on all nodes and as I understand oracle use a dot in the protocol name (TLSv1.2) and I use the same protocol name and cipher names in the 3.0.14 nodes and the one I try to upgrade to 3.11.1. On 2018-01-17 15:02, Georg Brandemann wrote: If i remember correctly the pro

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-17 Thread Georg Brandemann
If i remember correctly the protocol names differ between some JRE vendors. With IBM Java for instance the protocol name would be TLSv12 ( without . ). Are you using the same JRE on all nodes and is the protocol name and cipher names exactly the same on all nodes? 2018-01-17 14:51 GMT+01:00 Tomm

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-17 Thread Tommy Stendahl
Thanks for your response. I got it working by removing my protocol setting from the configuration on the 3.11.1 node so it use the default protocol setting, I'm not sure exactly how that change things so I need to investigate that. We don't have any custom ssl settings that should affect this

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-17 Thread Tommy Stendahl
Thanks for your response. I removed the protocol setting from the server_encryption_options in the 3.11.1 node so it use the default value instead and now it works. I have to analyse if this has any impact on my security requirements but at least its working now. /Tommy On 2018-01-16 17:26

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-17 Thread Stefan Podkowinski
I think what this error indicates is that a client is trying to connect using a SSLv2Hello handshake, while this protocol has been disabled on the server side. Starting with the mentioned ticket, we use the JVM default list of enabled protocols. What makes this issue a bit confusing, is that starti

Re: Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-16 Thread Michael Shuler
This looks like the post-POODLE commit: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CASSANDRA-10508 I think you might just set 'TLS' as in the example to use the JVM's preferred TLS protocol version. -- Michael On 01/16/2018 08:13 AM, Tommy Stendahl wrote: > Hi, > > I have problems upgrading a clust

Upgrade to 3.11.1 give SSLv2Hello is disabled error

2018-01-16 Thread Tommy Stendahl
Hi, I have problems upgrading a cluster from 3.0.14 to 3.11.1 but when I upgrade the first node it fails to gossip. I have server encryption enabled on all nodes with this setting: server_encryption_options:     internode_encryption: all     keystore: /usr/share/cassandra/.ssl/server/keystore