Re: Best partition type for Cassandra with JBOD

2014-05-23 Thread Robert Coli
On Tue, May 20, 2014 at 10:07 AM, Kevin Burton wrote: > This has not been my experience… In my benchmarks over the years noatime > has mattered. > Have you compared to the atime case or the relatime case? The point of the FAQ link posted is that the default behavior in XFS when you specify none

Re: Best partition type for Cassandra with JBOD

2014-05-20 Thread Kevin Burton
This has not been my experience… In my benchmarks over the years noatime has mattered. However, I might have not been as scientifically motivated to falsify the noatime hypothesis… specifically, I might just have accidentally used confirmation bias and assumed that noatime mattered and then moved

Re: Best partition type for Cassandra with JBOD

2014-05-19 Thread Bryan Talbot
For XFS, using noatime and nodirtime isn't really useful either. http://xfs.org/index.php/XFS_FAQ#Q:_Is_using_noatime_or.2Fand_nodiratime_at_mount_time_giving_any_performance_benefits_in_xfs_.28or_not_using_them_performance_decrease.29.3F On Sat, May 17, 2014 at 7:52 AM, James Campbell < ja...

Re: Best partition type for Cassandra with JBOD

2014-05-17 Thread James Campbell
Thanks for the thoughts! On May 16, 2014 4:23 PM, Ariel Weisberg wrote: Hi, Recommending nobarrier (mount option barrier=0) when you don't know if a non-volatile cache in play is probably not the way to go. A non-volatile cache will typically ignore write barriers if a given block device is co

Best partition type for Cassandra with JBOD

2014-05-16 Thread James Campbell
Hi all- What partition type is best/most commonly used for a multi-disk JBOD setup running Cassandra on CentOS 64bit? The datastax production server guidelines recommend XFS for data partitions, saying, "Because Cassandra can use almost half your disk space for a single file, use XFS when usin

Re: Best partition type for Cassandra with JBOD

2014-05-16 Thread Ariel Weisberg
Hi, Recommending nobarrier (mount option barrier=0) when you don't know if a non-volatile cache in play is probably not the way to go. A non-volatile cache will typically ignore write barriers if a given block device is configured to cache writes anyways. I am also skeptical you will see a bo

Re: Best partition type for Cassandra with JBOD

2014-05-16 Thread Kevin Burton
That and nobarrier… and probably noop for the scheduler if using SSD and setting readahead to zero... On Fri, May 16, 2014 at 10:29 AM, James Campbell < ja...@breachintelligence.com> wrote: > Hi all— > > > > What partition type is best/most commonly used for a multi-disk JBOD setup > running Ca