Re: AW: AW: should ant 'id' value be a static string

2009-12-21 Thread Matt Benson
Well, theoretically if some user were using a ${foo} construct as an explicit id, then yes, that would break BC, but I would imagine such situations to be extremely rare and wouldn't have a problem with adding property expansion to the id attribute. -Matt On Dec 21, 2009, at 7:27 AM, wrot

AW: AW: should ant 'id' value be a static string

2009-12-21 Thread Jan.Materne
>As one kind of resolutions work and not other one.. for id's. >Jan pl. let me know why such design.. Not sure, was before my time (2003) ;-) Changing that would on the other hand break backwards compatibility. Jan - To unsub