[Bug 606706] Re: Regression: HD spins down all the time after upgrade of pm-utils

2010-07-19 Thread Martin Pitt
upower itself does not use the on_ac_power script. But what would be interesting to see is the output of "sh -ex /usr/bin/on_ac_power" while your system is on AC. ** Summary changed: - Regression: HD spins down all the time after upgrade of pm-utils + [maverick] HD spins down all the time on AC

[Bug 606706] Re: Regression: HD spins down all the time after upgrade of pm-utils

2010-07-19 Thread Martin Pitt
Interesting, so you still get "Running hook /usr/lib/pm- utils/power.d/harddrive true" after you connect AC? Can you confirm that "upower --dump" says "on battery" while it's really on AC? -- [maverick] HD spins down all the time on AC https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/606706 You received this bug

[Bug 606706] Re: Regression: HD spins down all the time after upgrade of pm-utils

2010-07-18 Thread Christian Schürer-Waldheim
The output of "on_ac_power && echo yes || echo no" is as expected: yes while on ac and no while on battery. Nevertheless, the aggressive hard disk spin down is always active - no matter I'm on ac or not. Only disabling it manually helps. I have a Dell Latitude D620, if this is of any help. How c

[Bug 606706] Re: Regression: HD spins down all the time after upgrade of pm-utils

2010-07-18 Thread Michael Biebl
I can confirm the behaviour, when on battery. The hard disk spin downs are much too aggressive. Imho we also need to evaluate if the power saving justify this hook after all. One compromise could be, to install the harddrive hook but disable it by default. I can't confirm the problem though, when

[Bug 606706] Re: Regression: HD spins down all the time after upgrade of pm-utils

2010-07-17 Thread Christian Schürer-Waldheim
Monitoring /var/log/pm-powersave.log while removing and connecting the power supply, I get this: [quote] Running hook /usr/lib/pm-utils/power.d/harddrive true: Enabling power management for /dev/sda...Done. [/quote] So even the laptop is connected to mains power again, the hooks are run as being

[Bug 606706] Re: Regression: HD spins down all the time after upgrade of pm-utils

2010-07-17 Thread Christian Schürer-Waldheim
Martin and Michael, I subscribed you to this bug report because you made the recent changes in pm-utils. [quote] Current hooks when switching to battery: - [hal-cd-polling] Disable HAL's polling of CD drives for automounting them. Note that this HAL functionality is already obsolete