[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-05-26 Thread Launchpad Bug Tracker
This bug was fixed in the package computer-janitor - 2.0.1-0ubuntu1 --- computer-janitor (2.0.1-0ubuntu1) maverick; urgency=low * Bumping for Ubuntu. computer-janitor (2.0.1~ppa1) lucid; urgency=low * Display dialog in gtk version when another package manager is running, pre

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-04-08 Thread Barry Warsaw
After further discussion, it's been decided to not land CJ 2.0 in Lucid. I am going to back out the string changes and will get CJ 2.0 landed early in the Maverick cycle. For anybody seeing threading related crashes or freezes, please see my PPA. ** Changed in: computer-janitor (Ubuntu) St

Re: [Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-04-01 Thread Barry Warsaw
On Apr 01, 2010, at 01:01 PM, Martin Pitt wrote: >Thanks. This resolved the string changes, but of course the general >uncertainty about the completely new architecture remains. Since we are >now frozen for beta-2, perhaps you could launch a call for testing on >ubuntu-devel@, to collect some more

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-04-01 Thread Martin Pitt
Thanks. This resolved the string changes, but of course the general uncertainty about the completely new architecture remains. Since we are now frozen for beta-2, perhaps you could launch a call for testing on ubuntu-devel@, to collect some more feedback? -- [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-31 Thread Barry Warsaw
Hi Martin, lp:~barry/computer-janitor/ppa r233 resolves the outstanding issues I think. ** Branch linked: lp:~barry/computer-janitor/ppa -- [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/541990 You received this bug notification because you are a member of

Re: [Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-31 Thread Barry Warsaw
On Mar 31, 2010, at 03:51 PM, Martin Pitt wrote: >> Yes, the front-end currently throws DBusExceptions. What should it do >instead? > >I guess it should handle them gracefully, like restarting the backend or >crashing the UI as well, since otherwise the user will be left with a >nonfunctioning UI.

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-31 Thread Martin Pitt
> >- How does the frontend behave if the backend crashes? (Throwing DBusExceptions is a common phenomenon with dbus service backed programs, and hard to get right) > Yes, the front-end currently throws DBusExceptions. What should it do instead? I guess it should handle them gracefully, like resta

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-30 Thread Barry Warsaw
BTW, this merge proposal cleans a few of these things up: https://code.edge.launchpad.net/~barry/computer-janitor/ppa -- [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/541990 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which i

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-30 Thread Barry Warsaw
Martin asked for an audit of translatable string changes. Here they are to my best knowledge: Removed: * Essential package %s is missing. There may be problems with apt sources.list or Packages files may be missing? - Because apt verification happens in the dbus service now, there's no good

Re: [Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-29 Thread Barry Warsaw
Hi Martin, On Mar 29, 2010, at 06:37 AM, Martin Pitt wrote: >- Did that change any of the logic about which packages are considered >- "cruft"? I did not. All of that lives inside the computerjanitor Python package, which actually lives in Update Manager source package. I haven't touched any o

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-28 Thread Martin Pitt
- Did that change any of the logic about which packages are considered "cruft"? - Can you please attach a branch/patch for this, for a quick review? - Does it change any user-visible strings/break translations? - How does the frontend behave if the backend crashes? (Throwing DBusExceptions is a co

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-19 Thread Michael Vogt
A +1 from me on this. The old computer-janitor gtk UI has many issues, the threading tends to deadlock and crash randomly. The new dbus based design is much cleaner and much more stable. -- [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/541990 You received th

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFE] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-19 Thread Barry Warsaw
The package has undergone extensive testing by both myself and mvo. CJ 2.0 has more unit tests, and I have user tested the package many times using a Lucid VM. This allowed me to take disk snapshots before any system changing actions, so that I could repeatedly test, revert, test to ensure that e

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFE] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-19 Thread Barry Warsaw
** Attachment added: "build log" http://launchpadlibrarian.net/41303898/typescript -- [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/541990 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. -- ubu

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFE] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-19 Thread Barry Warsaw
** Attachment added: "dpkg -i output" http://launchpadlibrarian.net/41303424/typescript -- [FFe] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/541990 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. --

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFE] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-19 Thread Barry Warsaw
** Patch added: "Upstream NEWS file diff for CJ 2.0" http://launchpadlibrarian.net/41303070/news.diff -- [FFE] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition) https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/541990 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed

[Bug 541990] Re: [FFE] Upgrade Computer Janitor to 2.0 (dbus edition)

2010-03-19 Thread Barry Warsaw
Oh, CJ 2.0 requires python-argparse 1.1 which has already gone through the FFE and MIR process, and is just waiting for a sponsor to upload. mvo has offered to do this. Also, the gtk ui has been cleaned up so that the unused "Recommended" column is gone. That was a hard-coded no-op previously. -