[Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-09 Thread Robin Joinson
Ok Jamie, >From my point of view, I've had the opportunity to raise and discuss all my concerns and I believe the position of the Ubunu team is that things will stay the same in the Apparmor package. I guess my 'bug' is closed. Nevertheless, many thanks to the team for taking the time and effort

Re: [Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-09 Thread Jamie Strandboge
The package does quite a bit to make sure things don't break. Please see: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ApparmorProfileMigration Unfortunately, there is no way to reasonably detect every situation a user might have changed his or her system, however, the above migration strategies catch most cases (by f

[Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-07 Thread Robin Joinson
Ok, so apparmor doesn't like some local condition on my machine. The substance of my bug report is still the same. The package maintainer should configure the apparmor package so that it does these things: - at the pre-install phase, check for affected services and warn the admin when a service

Re: [Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-06 Thread Mathias Gug
On Fri, Jun 06, 2008 at 10:59:13PM -, Robin Joinson wrote: > MySQL isn't installed in /opt. The myslqd is the Ubuntu one in > /usr/sbin/mysqld. On this system, /usr/share is symlinked to /opt/share > and has been since the system was installed (and prior to the mysql > package being installed

[Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-06 Thread Robin Joinson
MySQL isn't installed in /opt. The myslqd is the Ubuntu one in /usr/sbin/mysqld. On this system, /usr/share is symlinked to /opt/share and has been since the system was installed (and prior to the mysql package being installed). The mysql package was upgraded a number of times with apt-get dist-u

[Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-06 Thread Kees Cook
If your mysql is installed out of /opt, it is not an Ubuntu version. :) ** Description changed: The problem seems to be caused by Apparmor. For example in /var/log/syslog: Mar 19 20:04:39 lyra kernel: [ 6979.352113] audit(1205957079.490:28): operation= "inode_permission" request_mas

[Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-05 Thread Robin Joinson
I didn't really want apparmor to be installed, but thanks for the tip. Nope, I didn't install apparmor-profiles; I don't believe apparmor is necessary for running mysql on Ubuntu. I was upgrading the whole system, to the best of my recollection, the version numbers were from 5.0.45 under Gutsy to

[Bug 204042] Re: mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04

2008-06-04 Thread Michael Nagel
** Changed in: apparmor (Ubuntu) Sourcepackagename: None => apparmor -- mysqld fails to start on upgrade 7.10->8.04 https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/204042 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list ubunt