[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2024-07-25 Thread Brian Murray
Ubuntu 23.04 (Lunar Lobster) has reached end of life, so this bug will not be fixed for that specific release. ** Changed in: libvirt (Ubuntu Lunar) Status: Incomplete => Won't Fix -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2022-05-18 Thread gutschke
Just to clarify things a little bit. I don't believe this is actually very "unusual hardware". I try to develop software for Raspberry Pi (a common hardware platform) on my laptop and have installed QEmu to do so. If I use libvirt to start QEmu, I run into this exact same problem. Starting QEmu dir

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2021-07-26 Thread Robie Basak
Thank you for your report. From the comments it has yet to be clarified whether there is a bug here, or missing support in libvirt/qemu for your particular requirements which might be considered a Wishlist feature request. Either way this seems like "unusual end-user configurations or uncommon har

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2021-07-23 Thread dann frazier
@Enoch: Thanks for clarifying your use case, it's clear that launching an accelerated raspi3b VM is your goal - apologies I couldn't be of more help. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/19368

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2021-07-22 Thread Enoch Leung
Hi Dann, Thanks for looking into it. I am trying pi 3b emulation at the moment, as I want to try things out with VMs instead of the real SBC. My target is to try things out before deploying to the real SBC, hence why I want to use emulation of specific machine type. I see that most tutorial onl

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2021-07-22 Thread dann frazier
Hi Enoch, Christian asked me to take a peek at this but, unfortunately, what you're trying to do here is outside of my wheelhouse. Generally when I'm running KVM ARM guests, I just use the "virt" model regardless of what the underlying kit is. The virt model provides a standard UEFI/KVM system (w

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2021-07-22 Thread Enoch Leung
Thanks for looking into it. 1. raspi3b or similar ARM machines do not support ACPI, so the snippet should not exist in libvirt VM's domain XML, or it will complain this or that, refusing to start just as you'd tried. That's also why my example machine XML does not have it. 2. without the snipp

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2021-07-22 Thread Christian Ehrhardt 
Hi Enoch. I wonder if, maybe, the definition you shared just asks for an impossible configuration. Indeed if it wants acpi, so let us add it. If you add

[Bug 1936831] Re: libvirt ACPI on unsupported machine

2021-07-21 Thread Christian Ehrhardt 
Hi, thanks for the report - I'm super busy this week and on PTO afterwards. So answers might be delayed a bit and I beg your pardon in advance. I have asked a few friends more into arm, maybe that provides a quick help. Otherwise I'll try to squeeze in some debugging. -- You received this bug not