[Bug 1389077] Re: [HP ProBook 4530s] Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU

2014-11-20 Thread William Katcher
As an experiment, I removed the powerclamp driver and monitored the temp sensors. The GPU never got close to high. The CPU has two thresholds, high of 86 C and critical of 100 C. With the powerclamp driver, the idle injection always kicked in at 86. Without, the temp stayed at around 99 C, never ev

[Bug 1389077] Re: [HP ProBook 4530s] Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU

2014-11-11 Thread William Katcher
My GPU seems fine, well under the high threshold. I can see what the logic is of throttling the CPU because the GPU is overheating--if the CPU is throttled then less data is being fed to the GPU so the GPU is indirectly slowed. But you're right, reducing the CPU by half is overkill. And that seems

[Bug 1389077] Re: [HP ProBook 4530s] Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU

2014-11-10 Thread William Katcher
The fans are working fine, although maybe not as fast as before, and the top tasks are java as expected. There is something here that is new behavior, but I can't quite pin what it is. Either: 1. The older kernels did not protect the CPU from overheating. 2. The older kernels used a different for

[Bug 1389077] Re: [HP ProBook 4530s] Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU

2014-11-05 Thread William Katcher
I found a workaround by rmmod intel_powerclamp. This removed the kidle_inject threads and the speed was returned to normal. However, I looked at my CPU temperature, and it was 87 deg C, over the high threshold. It is possible that the idle injection is a new kernel feature that is kicking in to pr

[Bug 1389077] Re: Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU

2014-11-04 Thread William Katcher
There are no warnings whatsoever in my syslog file about thermal temperature. I do see this message that seems to correspond with the slowdown: intel_powerclamp: Start idle injection to reduce power I have tried the 3.18.0-031800rc3-generic kernel. After running for a few minutes, I did not

[Bug 1389077] Re: Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU

2014-11-04 Thread William Katcher
** Tags added: kernel-bug-exists-upstream -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1389077 Title: Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.lau

[Bug 1389077] [NEW] Intel Powerclamp is Slowing CPU

2014-11-03 Thread William Katcher
Public bug reported: I upgraded from KUbuntu 14.04 to 14.10. Immediately, while playing minecraft with my daughter, I noticed the game was running very slowly. Even after closing the game, my web browsing slowed to a crawl. Looking at the processes in top, I noticed there were 4 tasks called kidl