Re: [tor-dev] v3 hidden services: inconsistencies between spec and implementation

2017-11-03 Thread inkylatenoth
On Sat, Oct 28, 2017 at 05:30:51PM +0300, George Kadianakis wrote: > That's a great post and thanks for catching all these issues and > innacuracies! We are definitely interested in consistency and fixing the > spec (and implementation if needed). No problem! I'm glad you found my post helpful. >

Re: [tor-dev] v3 hidden services: inconsistencies between spec and implementation

2017-10-28 Thread teor
On 29 Oct 2017, at 01:30, George Kadianakis wrote: >> # 220-ecc-ids-keys.txt Is this the latest version of the ECC ID specification? Usually, our proposals are integrated into the main spec documents after they are implemented. >> # 2.1 >> >> * 'The signature is formed by signing the first N-6

Re: [tor-dev] v3 hidden services: inconsistencies between spec and implementation

2017-10-28 Thread George Kadianakis
inkylatenoth writes: > Whilst implementing v3 hidden services myself I found some > inconsistencies between the specs and the current implementation. I > wanted to share these in case someone from the Tor organization wants to > update the specs and/or the implementation. > Hello inkylatenoth!

[tor-dev] v3 hidden services: inconsistencies between spec and implementation

2017-10-28 Thread inkylatenoth
Whilst implementing v3 hidden services myself I found some inconsistencies between the specs and the current implementation. I wanted to share these in case someone from the Tor organization wants to update the specs and/or the implementation. # rend-spec-v3.txt ## 2.4 * after decrypting the `su