Re: [tor-dev] v2 to v3 onion service transition

2016-09-14 Thread Ivan Markin
David Goulet: > The thing that worries me about the approach of: > "Publishes somewhere their v3 address and cross-cert*." > > ... is the amount of more traffic and complexity we had to the network for > such a thing. I for sure don't want Tor to maintain some sorts of registry > here just for

Re: [tor-dev] v2 to v3 onion service transition (was: "old style" hidden services after Prop224)

2016-09-14 Thread David Goulet
On 13 Sep (21:45:00), Ivan Markin wrote: > Forking this thread to discuss onion service transition path. > > David Goulet: > > The question arise now. Someone running a .onion upgrades her tor that > > supports v3, should we allow v2 to continue running or transition it to v3 > > or > > make them

Re: [tor-dev] v2 to v3 onion service transition (was: "old style" hidden services after Prop224)

2016-09-13 Thread Ivan Markin
Forking this thread to discuss onion service transition path. David Goulet: > The question arise now. Someone running a .onion upgrades her tor that > supports v3, should we allow v2 to continue running or transition it to v3 or > make them both happy together...? We haven't discuss this in depth