Re: [tor-dev] Comparing Proposals 295 and 308

2019-10-23 Thread Jean Paul Degabriele
Hello everyone, Below is our response to the main issues raised by Tomer in his previous email. We went into some detail in order to better convey the severity of the issues we raised. In summary the main points are the following: 1) The feedback in the polynomial hash is dangerous and renders th

[tor-dev] Comparing Proposals 295 and 308

2019-10-16 Thread Tomer Ashur
Dear all, Some time ago I sent to this mailing list a proposal for using the ADL construction to solve the crypto tagging attack and it was registered as Proposal 295. Then, about a month ago Jean Paul Degabriele sent another proposal aiming for the same, which was registered as Proposal 308. W