Re: [tor-dev] A ContactInfo specification

2017-11-09 Thread nusenu
> I added your note to Sebastian's ticket about publishing key expiry > information in descriptors. I like Sebastian's idea but I also agree to > your opt-in remark - which means that we will likely not get much data > at all (how many relay operators will opt-in vs. the effort to make that > possi

Re: [tor-dev] A ContactInfo specification

2017-11-09 Thread nusenu
teor: >> - OfflineMasterKey setting (0/1) >> - SigningKeyLifetime >> - Sandbox (0/1) > Yes, these are directly related to relay security, so if they can be linked > to the relay, they should be opt-in. I added your note to Sebastian's ticket about publishing key expiry information in descriptors

Re: [tor-dev] A ContactInfo specification

2017-10-21 Thread nusenu
teor: >> Do you consider the following torrc _settings_ too sensitive to publish >> by relays (without an aggregation scheme)? >> >> - OfflineMasterKey setting (0/1) >> - SigningKeyLifetime >> - Sandbox (0/1) > Yes, these are directly related to relay security, so if they can be linked > to the r

Re: [tor-dev] A ContactInfo specification

2017-10-21 Thread teor
On 21 Oct 2017, at 19:21, nusenu wrote: >> Automated statistics would be more reliable for these particular use cases. >> If the information is sensitive, it can be collected using a safe aggregation >> scheme (PrivCount as described in prop280, or similar). > > I agree that it would be desirabl

Re: [tor-dev] A ContactInfo specification

2017-10-21 Thread nusenu
Thank you for the feedback. teor: > In general, unstructured text should remain unstructured text. Relay ops are free to choose from the available options (unstructured and structured). > Automated statistics would be more reliable for these particular use cases. > If the information is sensitiv

Re: [tor-dev] A ContactInfo specification

2017-10-20 Thread teor
> On 20 Oct 2017, at 23:44, nusenu wrote: > > - collect additional (self-reported) relay metrics (for things like > atlas and https://nusenu.github.io/OrNetStats ) > - exmples: How many use tor's Sandbox/OfflineMasterKey/KIST feature? > - This data could provide tor developers with information o

[tor-dev] A ContactInfo specification

2017-10-20 Thread nusenu
Hello, an earlier version of this has been send to tor-relays [1] and I got some feedback from irl and relay operators via ML and github issues. Now I'd like to hear from the tor developer community. Please send your feedback until 2017-10-27. example ContactInfo: https://atlas.torproject.org/#d