Re: [tor-dev] [proposal] New Entry Guard Selection Algorithm

2015-11-05 Thread s7r
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 Hi isis, I am also not sure if we should have DYSTOPIC_GUARDS and UTOPIC_GUARDS sets disjoint. It hurts the already fragile load balancing for Guards and will cause lighter load on FascistFirewall Guards (ports 80/443). I think usually users behind

Re: [tor-dev] [proposal] New Entry Guard Selection Algorithm

2015-10-30 Thread George Kadianakis
Hello Isis, thanks for the proposal. Looks good! I think adding the logic for greater reachability of people behind FascistFirewalls makes sense and will be very helpful. Some comments on the proposal inlined below: > Filename: xxx-guard-selection.txt > Title: New Guard Selection Behaviou

Re: [tor-dev] [proposal] New Entry Guard Selection Algorithm

2015-10-29 Thread Nick Mathewson
On Thu, Oct 29, 2015 at 5:01 PM, isis wrote: > Hello, > > For your reviewing pleasure, may I present you with a new (draft) proposal for > a new entry guard selection algorithm, and associated data structures (with > reference implementations!). [0] The bulk of it is based upon George > Kadianaki

[tor-dev] [proposal] New Entry Guard Selection Algorithm

2015-10-29 Thread isis
Hello, For your reviewing pleasure, may I present you with a new (draft) proposal for a new entry guard selection algorithm, and associated data structures (with reference implementations!). [0] The bulk of it is based upon George Kadianakis' recent email and pseudocode. [1] [2] There are still