Re: [tor-dev] Understanding the guard/md issue (#21969)

2017-10-28 Thread teor
> On 29 Oct 2017, at 01:19, George Kadianakis wrote: > > Hey Tim, > > just wanted to ask a clarifying question wrt #21969. > > First of all there are various forms of #21969 (aka the "missing > descriptors for some of our primary entry guards" issue). Sometimes it > occurs for 10 mins and then

Re: [tor-dev] v3 hidden services: inconsistencies between spec and implementation

2017-10-28 Thread teor
On 29 Oct 2017, at 01:30, George Kadianakis wrote: >> # 220-ecc-ids-keys.txt Is this the latest version of the ECC ID specification? Usually, our proposals are integrated into the main spec documents after they are implemented. >> # 2.1 >> >> * 'The signature is formed by signing the first N-6

Re: [tor-dev] v3 hidden services: inconsistencies between spec and implementation

2017-10-28 Thread George Kadianakis
inkylatenoth writes: > Whilst implementing v3 hidden services myself I found some > inconsistencies between the specs and the current implementation. I > wanted to share these in case someone from the Tor organization wants to > update the specs and/or the implementation. > Hello inkylatenoth!

[tor-dev] Understanding the guard/md issue (#21969)

2017-10-28 Thread George Kadianakis
Hey Tim, just wanted to ask a clarifying question wrt #21969. First of all there are various forms of #21969 (aka the "missing descriptors for some of our primary entry guards" issue). Sometimes it occurs for 10 mins and then goes away, whereas for other people it disables their service permanent

[tor-dev] v3 hidden services: inconsistencies between spec and implementation

2017-10-28 Thread inkylatenoth
Whilst implementing v3 hidden services myself I found some inconsistencies between the specs and the current implementation. I wanted to share these in case someone from the Tor organization wants to update the specs and/or the implementation. # rend-spec-v3.txt ## 2.4 * after decrypting the `su