Re: solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-22 Thread Binoy Dalal
Oh OK. I see. So you want both the docs to have the same score? In that case, I don't think there's any other way of going about it other than writing your own custom similarity class. Maybe someone else can suggest something better. On Tue, 22 Dec 2015, 13:08 elisabeth benoit wrote: > hello, >

Re: solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-21 Thread elisabeth benoit
hello, That's what I did, like I wrote in my mail yesterday. In first case, solr computes max. In second case, he sums both results. That's why I dont get the same relative scoring between docs with the same query. 2015-12-22 8:30 GMT+01:00 Binoy Dalal : > Unless the content for both the docs i

Re: solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-21 Thread Binoy Dalal
Unless the content for both the docs is exactly the same it is highly unlikely that you will get the same score for the docs under different querying conditions. What you saw in the first case may have been a happy coincidence. Other than that it is very difficult to say why the scoring is differen

Re: solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-21 Thread elisabeth benoit
hello, yes in the second case I get one document with a higher score. the relative scoring between documents is not the same anymore. best regards, elisabeth 2015-12-22 4:39 GMT+01:00 Binoy Dalal : > I have one query. > In the second case do you get two records with the same lower scores or > j

Re: solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-21 Thread Binoy Dalal
I have one query. In the second case do you get two records with the same lower scores or just one record with a lower score and the other with a higher one? On Mon, 21 Dec 2015, 18:45 elisabeth benoit wrote: > Hello, > > I don't think the query is important in this case. > > After checking out

Re: solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-21 Thread elisabeth benoit
Hello, I don't think the query is important in this case. After checking out solr's debug output, I dont think the query norm is relevant either. I think the scoring changes because 1) in first case, I have same slop for catchall and name fields. Bot match pf2 pf3. In this case, solr uses max o

Re: solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-21 Thread Binoy Dalal
What is your query? On Mon, 21 Dec 2015, 14:37 elisabeth benoit wrote: > Hello all, > > I am using solr 4.10.1 and I have configured my pf2 pf3 like this > > catchall~0^0.2 name~0^0.21 synonyms^0.2 > catchall~0^0.2 name~0^0.21 synonyms^0.2 > > my search field (qf) is my catchall field > > I'v be

solr 4.10 I change slop in pf2 pf3 and query norm changes

2015-12-21 Thread elisabeth benoit
Hello all, I am using solr 4.10.1 and I have configured my pf2 pf3 like this catchall~0^0.2 name~0^0.21 synonyms^0.2 catchall~0^0.2 name~0^0.21 synonyms^0.2 my search field (qf) is my catchall field I'v been trying to change slop in pf2, pf3 for catchall and synonyms (going from 0, or default v