Re: difference between geospatial search from database angle and from solr angle

2011-04-10 Thread Yonik Seeley
On Sun, Apr 10, 2011 at 5:24 PM, Lance Norskog wrote: > Wait! How can you do distance calculations across different shards > efficiently? Basic spatial search (bounding box filter, radius filter, sort by distance) has no cross-document component, so "it just works" with distributed search. -Yon

Re: difference between geospatial search from database angle and from solr angle

2011-04-10 Thread Lance Norskog
Wait! How can you do distance calculations across different shards efficiently? On Thu, Apr 7, 2011 at 7:19 AM, Smiley, David W. wrote: > I haven't used PostGIS so I can't offer a real comparison. I think if you > were to try out both, you'd be impressed with Solr's performance/scalability > th

Re: difference between geospatial search from database angle and from solr angle

2011-04-07 Thread Smiley, David W.
I haven't used PostGIS so I can't offer a real comparison. I think if you were to try out both, you'd be impressed with Solr's performance/scalability thanks in large part to its sharding. But for "functionality richness" in so far as geospatial is concerned, that's where Solr currently comes s

Re: difference between geospatial search from database angle and from solr angle

2011-04-07 Thread Erick Erickson
Have you looked at solr sharding? Best Erick On Thu, Apr 7, 2011 at 2:24 AM, Sean Bigdatafun wrote: > Thanks, David. > > I am thinking of a scenario that billions of objects, whose indices are too > big for a single machine to serve the indexing, to serve the querying. Is > there any sharding me

Re: difference between geospatial search from database angle and from solr angle

2011-04-06 Thread Sean Bigdatafun
Thanks, David. I am thinking of a scenario that billions of objects, whose indices are too big for a single machine to serve the indexing, to serve the querying. Is there any sharding mechanism? Can you give a comparison between solr-based geospatial search and PostGIS based geospatial search?

Re: difference between geospatial search from database angle and from solr angle

2011-04-06 Thread David Smiley (@MITRE.org)
Sean, Geospatial search in Lucene/Solr is of course implemented based on Lucene's underlying index technology. That technology was originally just for text but it's been adapted very successfully for numerics and querying ranges too. The only mature geospatial field type in Solr 3.1 is LatLonTy