Re: SolrCloud config question and zookeeper

2014-10-28 Thread Shawn Heisey
On 10/28/2014 3:42 AM, Bernd Fehling wrote: > Thanks for the explanations. > > My idea about 4 zookeepers is a result of having the same software > (java, zookeeper, solr, ...) installed on all 4 servers. > But yes, I don't need to start a zookeeper on the 4th server. > > 3 other machines outside

Re: SolrCloud config question and zookeeper

2014-10-28 Thread Markus Jelsma
On Tuesday 28 October 2014 10:42:11 Bernd Fehling wrote: > Thanks for the explanations. > > My idea about 4 zookeepers is a result of having the same software > (java, zookeeper, solr, ...) installed on all 4 servers. > But yes, I don't need to start a zookeeper on the 4th server. > > 3 other mac

Re: SolrCloud config question and zookeeper

2014-10-28 Thread Bernd Fehling
Thanks for the explanations. My idea about 4 zookeepers is a result of having the same software (java, zookeeper, solr, ...) installed on all 4 servers. But yes, I don't need to start a zookeeper on the 4th server. 3 other machines outside the cloud for ZK seams a bit oversized. And you have anot

Re: SolrCloud config question and zookeeper

2014-10-28 Thread Daniel Collins
As Michael says, you really want an odd number of zookeepers in order to meet the quorum requirements (which based on your comments you seem to be aware of). There is nothing "wrong" with 4 ZKs as such, just that it doesn't buy you anything above having 3, so its one more that might go wrong and c

Re: SolrCloud config question and zookeeper

2014-10-28 Thread Bernd Fehling
Yes, garbage collection is a very good argument to have external zookeepers. I haven't thought about that. But does this also mean seperate server for each zookeeper or can they live side by side with solr on the same server? What is the problem with 4 zookeepers beside that I have no real gain a

Re: SolrCloud config question and zookeeper

2014-10-27 Thread Michael Della Bitta
You want external zookeepers. Partially because you don't want your Solr garbage collections holding up zookeeper availability, but also because you don't want your zookeepers going offline if you have to restart Solr for some reason. Also, you want 3 or 5 zookeeepers, not 4 or 8. On 10/27/14