Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-09-11 Thread Mark Miller
On Sep 9, 2011, at 1:09 PM, Pulkit Singhal wrote: > I think I understand it a bit better now but wouldn't mind some validation. > > 1) solr.xml does not become part of ZooKeeper Right - currently it does not. Info is put there to tell Solr how to connect to zookeeper and register the cores. >

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-09-09 Thread Pulkit Singhal
I think I understand it a bit better now but wouldn't mind some validation. 1) solr.xml does not become part of ZooKeeper 2) The default looks like this out-of-box: so that may leave one wondering where the core's association to a collection name is made? It can be made like so: a) sta

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-09-09 Thread Pulkit Singhal
Hello Jan, You've made a very good point in (b). I would be happy to make the edit to the wiki if I understood your explanation completely. When you say that it is "looking up what collection that core is part of" ... I'm curious how a core is being put under a particular collection in the first

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-06-11 Thread Lance Norskog
Replication's polling technique does not scale to massively multicore environments. What is the official answer for this problem? "Use ZK and cloud?" On Sat, Jun 11, 2011 at 7:11 AM, Mark Miller wrote: > Jan, I feel terrible for leaving you hanging on this - I missed this email > entirely. Seem

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-06-11 Thread Mark Miller
Jan, I feel terrible for leaving you hanging on this - I missed this email entirely. Seems some of these should be made JIRA issues if they are not already? bq. j) Question: Is ReplicationHandler ZK-aware yet? As I think you now know, not yet ;) - Mark On Feb 14, 2011, at 4:40 PM, Jan Høydahl

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-06-11 Thread Mark Miller
Well yikes - I dropped the ball here... Apologies...my time to keep up with the user list was out the window for a bit! !*@#&! - Mark On Feb 10, 2011, at 5:45 PM, thorsten wrote: > > Hi Mark, hi all, > > I just got a customer request to conduct an analysis on the state of > SolrCloud. > >

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-02-14 Thread Jan Høydahl
Some more comments: f) For consistency, the JAVA OPTIONS should all be prefixed with solr.* even if they are related to embedded ZK -Dsolr.hostPort=8900 -Dsolr.zkRun -Dsolr.zkHost=localhost:9900 -Dsolr.zkBootstrap_confdir=./solr/conf g) I often share parts of my config between cores, e.g. a

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-02-10 Thread thorsten
Hi Mark, hi all, I just got a customer request to conduct an analysis on the state of SolrCloud. He wants to see SolrCloud part of the next solr 1.5 release and is willing to sponsor our dev time to close outstanding bugs and open issues that may prevent the inclusion of SolrCloud in the next r

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-02-10 Thread Jan Høydahl
Hi, I have so far just tested the examples and got a N by M cluster running. My feedback: a) First of all, a major update of the SolrCloud Wiki is needed, to clearly state what is in which version, what are current improvement plans and get rid of outdated stuff. That said I think there are ma

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-02-10 Thread Mark Miller
On Jan 20, 2011, at 12:49 AM, Grijesh wrote: > > Hi Mark, > > I was just working on SolrCloud for my R&D and I got a question in my Mind. > Since in SolrCloud the configuration files are being shared on all Cloud > instances and If I have different configuration files for different cores > then

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-01-23 Thread Sean Bigdatafun
Could you please give a pointer to the SolrCloud architecture? Could you please give a comprehensive explanation between it and Katta? * targetted app difference? * scalability difference? * flexibility difference and so on Thanks, Sean On Wed, Jan 19, 2011 at 12:07 PM, Mark Mille

Re: SolrCloud Feedback

2011-01-19 Thread Grijesh
Hi Mark, I was just working on SolrCloud for my R&D and I got a question in my Mind. Since in SolrCloud the configuration files are being shared on all Cloud instances and If I have different configuration files for different cores then how can I manage it by my Zookeeper managed SolrCloud.