Re: Hierarchical Facets

2007-03-09 Thread Erik Hatcher
On Mar 8, 2007, at 10:52 PM, Chris Hostetter wrote: or something like... Dir1 Subdir1 SubSubDir1 ...but this is why Hierarchical facets are hard. I've not yet tackled hierarchical facets myself despite the demand being there. It seems there are various ways this could be implemented,

RE: Hierarchical Facets

2007-03-08 Thread Chris Hostetter
: Dir1 : Dir1/Subdir1 : Dir1/Subdir1/SubSubDir1 or something like... Dir1 Subdir1 SubSubDir1 ...but this is why Hierarchical facets are hard. (it just occured to me that this is a differnet hiearchical facets thread then the one i thought it was .. you may want to check the arcives for some

RE: Hierarchical Facets

2007-03-07 Thread Binkley, Peter
duplicate the info in multiple fields like that, I'd be happier. Peter -Original Message- From: Chris Hostetter [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, March 07, 2007 10:47 AM To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org Subject: Re: Hierarchical Facets Assuming I'm understanding your q

Re: Hierarchical Facets

2007-03-07 Thread Chris Hostetter
d the number of files under each that match. : Date: Wed, 07 Mar 2007 10:11:54 -0500 : From: Andrew Nagy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> : Reply-To: solr-user@lucene.apache.org : To: Andrew Nagy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> : Cc: solr-user@lucene.apache.org : Subject: Re: Hierarchical Facets : : Hmm ... I

Re: Hierarchical Facets

2007-03-07 Thread Andrew Nagy
Hmm ... I had a brain storm. Could I do something like this: Dir1/Subdir1/SubSubDir1 Then query collection:"Dir1/Subdir1" and get the facets on collection at that point to see all of the subsubdirectories? Is their any better method? Andrew Andrew Nagy wrote: I am running into a stumbling b

Re: Hierarchical Facets?

2006-11-03 Thread Chris Hostetter
: You know ... i keep hearing about flamenco, one of these days i should : really take it for test drive and see what's under the hood. i still haven't looked under the hood, but i did puruse the owners manual... http://flamenco.berkeley.edu/data.html ...flamenco requires that all of y

Re: Hierarchical Facets?

2006-11-03 Thread David Legg
I don't know about that ... CNET has hundreds of thousands of products, with tens of thousands facet constraints ... and Solr seems to be doing ok for us :) Touché... I'm impressed :-) Still... I've got to write an application that will allow users to assign a detailed subject classificat

Re: Hierarchical Facets?

2006-11-03 Thread Chris Hostetter
: creating a generic facet framework. It would be interesting to know if : any work has been published which enumerates the design patterns : involved. I found Marti Hearst's research paper "Design Recommendations : for Hierarchical Faceted Search" very useful... : http://flamenco.berkeley.edu/p

Re: Hierarchical Facets?

2006-11-02 Thread David Legg
Chris, : > Are there any ideas on how to support hierarchical facets? It may be hard to roll out a truely "generic" way of sorting hierarchical counts that would be usefull for people. Thanks for the examples. I see what you mean about the difficulty in creating a generic facet framework

Re: Hierarchical Facets?

2006-11-02 Thread David Legg
Hi Yonik, Are there any ideas on how to support hierarchical facets? I've thought of some optimizations and general approach (not yet implemented) when it's a strict hierarchy. Thanks for your comments. Of the two approaches you mention (storing the full tag path or creating a strict facet hi

Re: Hierarchical Facets?

2006-11-02 Thread Chris Hostetter
: > My main interest : > is in Solr's fledgling support for faceted search. : > : > Are there any ideas on how to support hierarchical facets? there are two different things that fall under the heading of "hierarchical facets", and they can be very differnet... The first usage is when the word "

Re: Hierarchical Facets?

2006-11-02 Thread Yonik Seeley
On 11/2/06, David Legg <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I've just discovered Solr and realized its potential! Welcome! My main interest is in Solr's fledgling support for faceted search. Are there any ideas on how to support hierarchical facets? I've thought of some optimizations and general app