Re: CollapsingQParserPlugin returning different result set

2014-03-18 Thread shamik
Joel, I had a discussion with you earlier related ngroup inconsistent number when you suggested to use the composite id to make sure that identical (ADSKDedup) fields are available in the same shard. Here's the thread --> http://lucene.472066.n3.nabble.com/SolrCloud-Result-Grouping-vs-Collaps

Re: CollapsingQParserPlugin returning different result set

2014-03-18 Thread Joel Bernstein
Hi Shamik, I see that you are using distributed search. With the CollapsingQParserPlugin you need to have all the documents that are in the same group on the same shard. Is that the way you have the documents indexed? Joel Joel Bernstein Search Engineer at Heliosearch On Mon, Mar 17, 2014 at

Re: CollapsingQParserPlugin returning different result set

2014-03-17 Thread shamik
Hi Joel, Thanks for taking a look into this. Here's the information you had requested.*ADSKDedup:*I've attached separate files for debug information for each query.Let me know if you need any information.Regards,Shamik CollapsingQParserPlugin_Query_Debug.txt

Re: CollapsingQParserPlugin returning different result set

2014-03-15 Thread Joel Bernstein
Hi Shamik, You should be seeing the same result counts with grouping and the CollapsingQParserPlugin, unless there are null values in the collapse field. Let's see if we can figure out what the issue is. Can you post the schema.xml field type definition for the ADSKDedup field? Also can you post