Re: [R-pkg-devel] CRAN policies with regards to runnable examples

2019-10-01 Thread Mark van der Loo
My experience is somewhat similar to that of Hong Ooi. An initial submission got refused. During resubmission I explained the necessity of \dontrun{} in certain cases and it was accepted. So the basic policy here is 'comply or explain'. >From now on, when I need to place a \dontrun{} anywhere, I

Re: [R-pkg-devel] CRAN policies with regards to runnable examples

2019-10-01 Thread Hong Ooi via R-package-devel
Hm, up to now my AzureR packages haven't met with any issues, and they are basically API wrappers. I did have one reviewer ask for runnable examples when I submitted one package, but replying and pointing out the issues you mention cleared things up. I did cc Uwe Ligges in the reply, who approv

Re: [R-pkg-devel] CRAN policies with regards to runnable examples

2019-10-01 Thread Dr. rer. nat. Michael Thrun
Hello Jim, thank you for asking this question. I would also like to have a standard solution for this problem. Best Regards Michael Michael Thrun Postdoctoral Scholar Databionics AG, Mathematics and Computer Science Philipps-Universität Marburg Hans-Meerwein-Straße 6, 04A28 D-35032 Marburg Ph