Re: [R] NLS results different from Excel -- Tricky fortunes nomination

2013-03-14 Thread John Kane
No , but please RSVP if you disagree with me. John Kane Kingston ON Canada > -Original Message- > From: cl...@ecy.wa.gov > Sent: Thu, 14 Mar 2013 09:28:46 -0700 (PDT) > To: gunter.ber...@gene.com > Subject: Re: [R] NLS results different from Excel -- Tricky fortun

Re: [R] NLS results different from Excel -- Tricky fortunes nomination

2013-03-14 Thread Clint Bowman
Following up on Bert's nomination, may I take one from a recent email I received? "The second file is air concentrations against frequencies plotted by SAS; however we don't have the SAS statistical package..." I thought the original name for SAS was Statistical Analysis System--am I missing

Re: [R] NLS results different from Excel

2013-02-20 Thread Marc Schwartz
Just as an FYI, there is the NISTnls package on CRAN by Doug Bates: http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/NISTnls/index.html There have also been threads over the years touching on some of the issues in replicating the NIST results, for example: http://tolstoy.newcastle.edu.au/R/devel/06/0

Re: [R] NLS results different from Excel -- Tricky fortunes nomination

2013-02-20 Thread Rolf Turner
I think that this nomination is a Good Idea! cheers, Rolf On 02/21/2013 06:50 AM, Bert Gunter wrote: Folks: I thought the following excerpt from Bruce McCullough's post would be a good candidate for the R fortunes package -- except that it's about Excel, not R! So I nominate it.

Re: [R] NLS results different from Excel -- Tricky fortunes nomination

2013-02-20 Thread Bert Gunter
Folks: I thought the following excerpt from Bruce McCullough's post would be a good candidate for the R fortunes package -- except that it's about Excel, not R! So I nominate it... but leave it to others to say whether it's really "qualified" to be nominated. "The idea that the Excel solver

Re: [R] NLS results different from Excel

2013-02-20 Thread Bruce McCullough
The idea that the Excel solver "has a good reputation for being fast and accurate" does not withstand an examination of the Excel solver's ability to solve the StRD nls test problems. Solver's ability is abysmal. 13 of 27 "answers" have zero accurate digits, and three more have fewer than tw