Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-12 Thread S Ellison
>>> "Stas Kolenikov" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> 11/02/2008 18:54 >>> > I would think the FDA regulations could go as far as >specific SAS syntax, or at least to specify SAS PROCs to be used. This is unnecessary caution. FDA (like the MHRA in the UK, where I come from) should not endorse a single suppl

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread Stas Kolenikov
On 2/11/08, Paul Gilbert <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Stas Kolenikov wrote: > > ... > > Training researchers of tomorrow might be great, but ifyour students get > on > > the market in the end of the semester, they won't have the luxury of > waiting > > until R becomes THE package of choice. > > >

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread Neil Shephard
Neil Shephard wrote: > > (Most) of this problem isn't negated when using R. Start a new job and > use the (excellent, extensible, and free) software that you've been using > for years. > Apologies for the double negative, that should have read "(Most) of this problem _is_ negated when using

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread Paul Gilbert
Stas Kolenikov wrote: > ... > Training researchers of tomorrow might be great, but ifyour students get on > the market in the end of the semester, they won't have the luxury of waiting > until R becomes THE package of choice. > Not being a teacher, I usually follow these discussions with a bit o

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread David Whiting
On Mon, Feb 11, 2008 at 07:37:04AM -0800, Neil Shephard wrote: > > > > Arin Basu-3 wrote: > > > > Comment 2: > > > > Finally, on a minor point, why is "R" the statistical software being > > used? SPSS is probably more widely available in the workplace – > > certainly in areas of social policy

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread Neil Shephard
Arin Basu-3 wrote: > > Comment 2: > > Finally, on a minor point, why is "R" the statistical software being > used? SPSS is probably more widely available in the workplace – > certainly in areas of social policy etc. " (Prof NB) > > What struck me in the above is the "probably". How probabl

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread Bernard Leemon
Hi Arin, Others have commented wisely an your first issue. As for your 2nd issue, I had my own concerns about using R in undergraduate teaching because I had always used a point-and-click program for that level. I should not have worried. The current generation has been typing on their keyboards

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread Stas Kolenikov
I've been teaching an intro stats class to engineering students (who are better in calculus and math than med students, I would imagine), and use of R has never been received very warmly. I might not be teaching it right, but their (quite valid, from their standpoint) concerns were that they would

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread Longinus
I will also evaluate what did the students used before in the introductory statistics class and how proficient they have become in using it. If they only barely touched it, I will use my class as a chance to further refine their familiarity with the software they saw before. Tool is tool, I conside

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread bartjoosen
You can use a GUI to teach R, so the programming-style is gone. But using the command line aproach, it forces you to think about your analysis. In an GUI, it's easy to point and click, without knowing what you are doing. With the command line, you know where you start, and from there you go to the

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-11 Thread John Fox
Dear Arin, > -Original Message- > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > project.org] On Behalf Of Arin Basu > Sent: February-10-08 10:41 PM > To: r-help@r-project.org > Subject: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal > comments &

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-10 Thread Liviu Andronic
Hello Arin, If your future students do not know statistics, you might consider buffering their introduction to R with the help of a GUI package, such as Rcmdr (if functionality is missing, you could add it yourself via the plugin infrastructure). Another way to help students would be to direct the

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-10 Thread Spencer Graves
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > On Behalf Of Arin Basu > Sent: Monday, 11 February 2008 1:41 PM > To: r-help@r-project.org > Subject: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal > comments > > Hi All, > > I am scheduled to teach a graduate course on research metho

Re: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-10 Thread Bill.Venables
EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Arin Basu Sent: Monday, 11 February 2008 1:41 PM To: r-help@r-project.org Subject: [R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments Hi All, I am scheduled to teach a graduate course on research methods in health sciences at a university. While draftin

[R] Using R in a university course: dealing with proposal comments

2008-02-10 Thread Arin Basu
Hi All, I am scheduled to teach a graduate course on research methods in health sciences at a university. While drafting the course proposal, I decided to include a brief introduction to R, primarily with an objective to enable the students to do data analysis using R. It is expected that enrolled