Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-10 Thread SIES 73
> In the case the metadata are stored in a list, that interface enforces the > building of a list. > (I said to ignore implementation for now, but paradoxically this made me > consider possible implementations). Creating the list on the fly if it's not stored internally as a list should be chea

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread Laurent Gautier
be fewer. * `dim<-`, but this may raise the same problem of coercing dimmeta of different classes. Disabling "dim<-" is, I think, choosing sanity for now. ...and I agree with the rest of your comments. Same for me (about your comments). This thread seems to be leading to som

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread Laurent Gautier
case can already be modelled by a data.frame. L. Enrique -Original Message- From: Laurent Gautier [mailto:lgaut...@gmail.com] Sent: jueves, 09 de julio de 2009 14:15 Cc: Heinz Tuechler; Bengoechea Bartolomé Enrique (SIES 73); Tony Plate; Henrik Bengtsson; r-devel@r-project.org Subject:

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread SIES 73
ique (SIES 73); Tony Plate; Henrik Bengtsson; r-devel@r-project.org Subject: Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes Starting by working on an interface for such object(s) is probably the first step toward a unified solution, and this before about if and how R attributes are used. It w

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread SIES 73
ise. * `dim<-`, but this may raise the same problem of coercing dimmeta of different classes. ...and I agree with the rest of your comments. Best, Enrique -Original Message- From: Laurent Gautier [mailto:lgaut...@gmail.com] Sent: jueves, 09 de julio de 2009 14:15 Cc: Heinz Tuechle

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread Laurent Gautier
Starting by working on an interface for such object(s) is probably the first step toward a unified solution, and this before about if and how R attributes are used. It would also help to ensure a smooth transition from the existing classes implementing a similar solution (first the interface i

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread Heinz Tuechler
iginal Message- From: Heinz Tuechler [mailto:tuech...@gmx.at] Sent: jueves, 09 de julio de 2009 10:56 To: Bengoechea Bartolomé Enrique (SIES 73); Tony Plate; r-devel@r-project.org Cc: Henrik Bengtsson Subject: Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes At 10:01 09.07.2009, SIES 73 wrote: >

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread SIES 73
everal classes (xts, timeSeries, AnnotatedDataFrame, etc.) As you point, this could offer a unified design for a common need. Enrique -Original Message- From: Heinz Tuechler [mailto:tuech...@gmx.at] Sent: jueves, 09 de julio de 2009 10:56 To: Bengoechea Bartolomé Enrique (SIES 73); Tony

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread Heinz Tuechler
with 3 elements, something like: > attr(x, "attr.subset.with") <- list(object=..., dims=..., cells=...) Would something like this make sense for R-core --either for standard arrays or as a new class-- or would it be better implemented in a package? Enrique -Original Me

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-09 Thread SIES 73
) <- list(object=..., dims=..., cells=...) Would something like this make sense for R-core --either for standard arrays or as a new class-- or would it be better implemented in a package? Enrique -Original Message- From: Tony Plate [mailto:tpl...@acm.org] Sent: miércoles, 08 de julio d

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-08 Thread Tony Plate
There have been times when I've thought this could be useful too. One way to go about it could be to introduce a special attribute that controls how attributes are dealt with in subsetting, e.g., "attr.dimname.like". The contents of this would be character data; on subsetting, any attribute t

Re: [Rd] Suggestion: Dimension-sensitive attributes

2009-07-08 Thread SIES 73
Hi, I agree with Henrik that his suggestion to have "dimension vector attributes" working like dimnames (see below) would be an extremely useful infrastructure adittion to R. If this is not considered for R-core, I am happy to try to implement this in a package, as a new class. And possibly do