Re: [Rd] default arguments in generics and methods

2006-10-21 Thread John Chambers
You're conflating 3 different things here: how methods are selected, how R treats missing arguments, and how the standardGeneric() call is implemented. Maybe more relevant, if this question is motivated by a practical need, you may want to rethink what the generic function does. "Nonstandard"

[Rd] default arguments in generics and methods

2006-10-19 Thread Parlamis Franklin
i believe the following is true but would appreciate confirmation that it is intended behavior and will continue: if a default argument is employed in the definition of a generic function, and the generic is called with the argument in question (call it 'ARG') missing, then the method for si