Re: [Rd] Possible GPL Violation (Ian Fellows)

2008-10-23 Thread Rory.WINSTON
The law books were more interesting than the girlfriend... Ouch!!! But this does raise one of the issues I have with the GPL and the GPL family of licenses - the constant confusion around what is and what is not permissible. It's a gray area (possibly deliberately so), and most coversations end

Re: [Rd] Possible GPL Violation

2008-10-22 Thread Barry Rowlingson
2008/10/22 Ian Fellows <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Perhaps my understanding of GPL is lacking, but isn't this the reason that > GPL is different for LGPL? Linking to functions is allowed in the lesser > license, but not in GPL. > > From the gpl faq: >

Re: [Rd] Possible GPL Violation

2008-10-22 Thread Peter Dalgaard
Ian Fellows wrote: Hi All, I was cruising around today, and came across a company (ZumaStat) that adds additional statistics functionality to SPSS. From the Website: http://www.zumastat.com/robust_statistics.htm "ZumaStat provides a user friendly interface to access powerful stat

Re: [Rd] Possible GPL Violation

2008-10-22 Thread Ian Fellows
re I'm going astray (as I go astray often). -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Barry Rowlingson Sent: Wednesday, October 22, 2008 2:18 PM To: Ian Fellows Cc: r-devel@r-project.org Subject: Re: [Rd] Possible GPL Violation > It seems unl

Re: [Rd] Possible GPL Violation

2008-10-22 Thread Barry Rowlingson
> It seems unlikely that the functionality of this program can be separated > from the R-packages upon which it relies, thus making them one work subject > to GPL. Does anyone have any experience with this software/company? Any > thoughts? They're not distributing R itself: "You must have R on

[Rd] Possible GPL Violation

2008-10-22 Thread Ian Fellows
Hi All, I was cruising around today, and came across a company (ZumaStat) that adds additional statistics functionality to SPSS. >From the Website: http://www.zumastat.com/robust_statistics.htm "ZumaStat provides a user friendly interface to access powerful statistical programs on robu