Re: [Rd] formula(model.frame(..)) is misleading

2018-12-21 Thread William Dunlap via R-devel
I don't have a copy of SV4 (or SV3, where model.frame was introduced), but S+ 8.3 (based on SV4) puts the class "model.frame" on model.frame()'s return value but has no methods (in the default packages) for class "model.frame". Perhaps that is why R omitted the class. However, S+ 8.3's (and probl

Re: [Rd] formula(model.frame(..)) is misleading

2018-12-21 Thread Fox, John
Dear Martin, Since no one else has picked up on this, I’ll take a crack at it: The proposal is to define the S3 class of model-frame objects as c(“model.frame”, “data.frame”) (not the formal class of these objects, even though this feature was coincidentally introduced in S4). That’s unlikely