On Tue., 3 Mar. 2020, 2:11 pm Kyle Stanley, wrote:
> > In most cases of a first-time poster that I've seen, the poster probably
> doesn't have the understanding needed to conduct a proper search of the
> mailing list. That's why I suggest responding with some genuine help (i.e.
> taking their ide
On 3/3/2020 2:18 AM, Serhiy Storchaka wrote:
03.03.20 01:03, Skip Montanaro пише:
Atm we don't have an index of ideas, apart from pep 3099, and I'm
not sure we can make one (can we?), so I do not see a way to prevent
this from happening.
Maybe an informational PEP which briefly lists rejected
On Tue, 3 Mar 2020 at 07:27, Serhiy Storchaka wrote:
> 03.03.20 01:03, Skip Montanaro пише:
> >> Atm we don't have an index of ideas, apart from pep 3099, and I'm not
> sure we can make one (can we?), so I do not see a way to prevent this from
> happening.
> >
> > Maybe an informational PEP which
The webmaster list sends an auto-response to new posters. If something like
that could happen on python-dev too, as long as the advice was clear enough
the list could then simply ignore such requests, knowing that the
auto-responder had taken care of it. This could drive posters to
python-list or p
03.03.20 01:03, Skip Montanaro пише:
Atm we don't have an index of ideas, apart from pep 3099, and I'm not sure we
can make one (can we?), so I do not see a way to prevent this from happening.
Maybe an informational PEP which briefly lists rejected ideas?
There is a risk to accept this PEP a
> In most cases of a first-time poster that I've seen, the poster probably
doesn't have the understanding needed to conduct a proper search of the
mailing list. That's why I suggest responding with some genuine help (i.e.
taking their idea at face value and explaining what's wrong with it).
It mig
On Mon, Mar 2, 2020 at 2:42 PM Bar Harel wrote:
> What I usually do btw is just search on mailman. Perhaps we can guide
> people to search on mailman before suggesting an idea?
>
We could add that suggestion to the "welcome to this list" email. I
honestly don't know if we send out such emails, b
> Atm we don't have an index of ideas, apart from pep 3099, and I'm not sure we
> can make one (can we?), so I do not see a way to prevent this from happening.
Maybe an informational PEP which briefly lists rejected ideas?
Presumably, they'd normally come up in python-ideas, python-list or
python
What I usually do btw is just search on mailman. Perhaps we can guide
people to search on mailman before suggesting an idea?
On Tue, Mar 3, 2020 at 12:30 AM Bar Harel wrote:
> I wrote it and take full responsibility, did not mean to be disrespectful.
> Afterall, it's not what any of us are here
I wrote it and take full responsibility, did not mean to be disrespectful.
Afterall, it's not what any of us are here for.
For repeated suggestions though, that were rejected once or more in the
past, what are the general guidelines of answering?
In this case, apart from the rejection reason, we w
10 matches
Mail list logo
