Re: [Python-Dev] Closing old bugs

2005-06-02 Thread Reinhold Birkenfeld
Raymond Hettinger wrote: >> I've seen some systems that solve this problem by allowing users to > "vote" >> for favorite bugs... then you can tell the "important" bugs because > they >> are more likely to have lots of votes. As I see it, Facundo is using a >> variant of that system. He is asking wh

Re: [Python-Dev] Closing old bugs

2005-06-02 Thread Raymond Hettinger
> I've seen some systems that solve this problem by allowing users to "vote" > for favorite bugs... then you can tell the "important" bugs because they > are more likely to have lots of votes. As I see it, Facundo is using a > variant of that system. He is asking whether there is *ONE PERSON* out >

Re: [Python-Dev] Closing old bugs

2005-06-02 Thread Michael Chermside
Raymond writes: > Is there anyone else on python-dev who thinks it's a bad idea to automatically > close reports without checking whether the issue is real? Raymond: I'm speaking up with some trepidation here, since I am NOT one of those who frequently closes bugs. But I think that at least somet

[Python-Dev] Closing old bugs

2005-06-01 Thread Raymond Hettinger
> > Old age and a missing OP is not sufficient reason to close a bug. > > > > But if closing a bug is an effective way of kicking things into life > > again... > > I'm seeing this effect in a lot of bugs I closed as old ones. That means they shouldn't have been closed and that we almost lost a v

Re: [Python-Dev] Closing old bugs

2005-06-01 Thread Facundo Batista
On 6/1/05, Michael Hudson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Old age and a missing OP is not sufficient reason to close a bug. > > But if closing a bug is an effective way of kicking things into life > again... I'm seeing this effect in a lot of bugs I closed as old ones. I think that using the mail

Re: [Python-Dev] Closing old bugs

2005-06-01 Thread Michael Hudson
"Raymond Hettinger" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > There should be some greater care exercised in closing old bugs. Possibly. OTOH, we have something like 900 open bugs to work on, and it's not like bug reporters can't re-open a bug report if they think it's been closed in error (this has happene

[Python-Dev] Closing old bugs

2005-05-31 Thread Raymond Hettinger
There should be some greater care exercised in closing old bugs. Marking them "deprecated" and then erasing them is only a good strategy if we have no means of reproducing the error or ascertaining what the OP was talking about. For instance, in www.python.org/sf/640553 , it was possible for a re