[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Kyle Stanley
> Could a bot be written to suggest upgraded markup for Misc/NEWS entries as a PR? Potentially, but to some degree, the decision of whether or not to use the Sphinx markup should be determined on a case by case basis, rather than indiscriminately applying the markup to every possible candidate. Ge

[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Kyle Stanley
> The ability to effectively use Python-specific Sphinx features in NEWS entries is a relatively new feature Ah, I think that would likely explain some of the inconsistent responses then. I think it would be worthwhile to add an example of using Sphinx and a brief explanation of when it can be use

[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Wes Turner
Could a bot be written to suggest upgraded markup for Misc/NEWS entries as a PR? Most e.g. class, method, and function references probably need ReST markup AND a more specific fully-qualified reference? Can class, method, and function lookups be done with the existing Sphinx API index? On Tuesda

[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Ned Deily
On Aug 13, 2019, at 15:31, Kyle Stanley wrote: > > In general, using many Python-specific Sphinx markup entities is fine: > > browsing though the consolidated blurb files for previous releases (and the > > resultant changelog html) shows uses of entities like :func: and :class:. > > Since it's

[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Kyle Stanley
> There seems to be some sentiment that it's perfectly fine to exclusively use plaintext in every news entry. Oops, that third sentence was a typo, I didn't intend to repeat myself there. On Tue, Aug 13, 2019 at 6:31 PM Kyle Stanley wrote: > > Note that there is an open devguide issue that requ

[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Kyle Stanley
> Note that there is an open devguide issue that requests improvements in the description of news entry processing Good to know, I'll look further into this issue and see if I can help with it. > In general, using many Python-specific Sphinx markup entities is fine: browsing though the consolidat

[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Ned Deily
On Aug 13, 2019, at 00:20, Kyle Stanley wrote: > On Tue, Aug 13, 2019 at 2:41 AM Mariatta wrote: > > I would like to understand why some developers dislike including it, even > > when the reST syntax is provided. > > This has something to do with the use of blurb/blurb-it. Both tools > specif

[Python-Dev] Re: Inline links in Misc/NEWS entries

2019-08-13 Thread Kyle Stanley
> * The BODY section should be a single paragraph of English text in ReST format. It should not use the following ReST markup features: > * section headers > * comments > * directives, citations, or footnotes > * Any features that require significant line breaks, like lists, definition lists, quote