Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Daniel Brown
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 15:08, Kyle Terry wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 12:05 PM, VamVan wrote: >> I believe in Community building. My only concern was the kind of language >> used is very intimidating , that's all. > > Are you referring to bad language? An unintended pun. Nice. ;-P --

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Kyle Terry
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 12:05 PM, VamVan wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 11:50 AM, Daniel Brown wrote: > >> On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 14:37, VamVan wrote: >> > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. >> >> It's a PHP-related general discussion, Vam. Perhaps not ent

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread VamVan
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 11:50 AM, Daniel Brown wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 14:37, VamVan wrote: > > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. > > It's a PHP-related general discussion, Vam. Perhaps not entirely > in good manners, but it's 100% relevant. Indeed,

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Kyle Terry
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 11:54 AM, Robert Cummings wrote: > On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 14:50 -0500, Daniel Brown wrote: > > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 14:37, VamVan wrote: > > > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. > > > > It's a PHP-related general discussion, Vam. Perha

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Eric Butera
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 2:37 PM, VamVan wrote: > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. > > > > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 11:03 AM, Kyle Terry wrote: > >> On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:59 AM, Robert Cummings > >wrote: >> >> > On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 10:50 -0800, Kyle Terry wro

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Robert Cummings
On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 14:50 -0500, Daniel Brown wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 14:37, VamVan wrote: > > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. > > It's a PHP-related general discussion, Vam. Perhaps not entirely > in good manners, but it's 100% relevant. Indeed,

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Daniel Brown
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 14:37, VamVan wrote: > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. It's a PHP-related general discussion, Vam. Perhaps not entirely in good manners, but it's 100% relevant. Indeed, this is the right place. That aside, as intelligent folks,

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Kyle Terry
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 11:45 AM, Robert Cummings wrote: > On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 11:37 -0800, VamVan wrote: > > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. > > Could you explain "burning our egos"? > > Cheers, > Rob. > -- > http://www.interjinn.com > Application and Templatin

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Robert Cummings
On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 11:37 -0800, VamVan wrote: > Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. Could you explain "burning our egos"? Cheers, Rob. -- http://www.interjinn.com Application and Templating Framework for PHP -- PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/) To

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread VamVan
Why are you guys Burning your egos here? Its not the right place. On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 11:03 AM, Kyle Terry wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:59 AM, Robert Cummings >wrote: > > > On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 10:50 -0800, Kyle Terry wrote: > > > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:35 AM, Daniel Brown >

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Kyle Terry
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:59 AM, Robert Cummings wrote: > On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 10:50 -0800, Kyle Terry wrote: > > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:35 AM, Daniel Brown wrote: > > > > > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 13:22, Kyle Terry wrote: > > > >> > > > > Aside from a few perl scripts, I have rewritten al

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Robert Cummings
On Mon, 2009-01-19 at 10:50 -0800, Kyle Terry wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:35 AM, Daniel Brown wrote: > > > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 13:22, Kyle Terry wrote: > > >> > > > Aside from a few perl scripts, I have rewritten all my bash scripts in > > PHP. > > > It's just easier to manage for me

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Tony Marston
""Daniel Brown"" wrote in message news:ab5568160901191010u2d4073aas33789f0c81183...@mail.gmail.com... > On Sun, Jan 18, 2009 at 12:36, Tony Marston > wrote: >> >> Really? In 2007 I single-handedly designed and built an ERP system with >> 130 >> database tables, 230 relationships and 1000 scree

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Kyle Terry
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:35 AM, Daniel Brown wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 13:22, Kyle Terry wrote: > >> > > Aside from a few perl scripts, I have rewritten all my bash scripts in > PHP. > > It's just easier to manage for me. > > /me nods. > >In 2001, I started rewriting a library o

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Daniel Brown
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 13:22, Kyle Terry wrote: >> > Aside from a few perl scripts, I have rewritten all my bash scripts in PHP. > It's just easier to manage for me. /me nods. In 2001, I started rewriting a library of Perl scripts I'd been building since 1995 (5.0.0.1), which meant rewr

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Kyle Terry
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:19 AM, Daniel Brown wrote: > On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 12:13, Per Jessen wrote: > > > > Yes, I am serious, and no, I don't write php extensions etc. I don't > > write many web apps anyway. I do use PHP quite a bit for command line > > stuff, in fact for >95% of my scri

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Daniel Brown
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 12:13, Per Jessen wrote: > > Yes, I am serious, and no, I don't write php extensions etc. I don't > write many web apps anyway. I do use PHP quite a bit for command line > stuff, in fact for >95% of my scripts. Same her, Per. I actually use PHP for more command-line

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Kyle Terry
On Mon, Jan 19, 2009 at 10:10 AM, Daniel Brown wrote: > On Sun, Jan 18, 2009 at 12:36, Tony Marston > wrote: > > > > Really? In 2007 I single-handedly designed and built an ERP system with > 130 > > database tables, 230 relationships and 1000 screens, all with PHP and > > without an ORM and stat

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Daniel Brown
On Sun, Jan 18, 2009 at 12:36, Tony Marston wrote: > > Really? In 2007 I single-handedly designed and built an ERP system with 130 > database tables, 230 relationships and 1000 screens, all with PHP and > without an ORM and static typing. This took me 6 months. If you can't equal > that then eithe

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Per Jessen
Eric Butera wrote: > On Sun, Jan 18, 2009 at 11:44 AM, Per Jessen wrote: >> I think that's at best an example of someone having chosen the wrong >> tool. I can easily appreciate the frustration. My own rule-of-thumb >> - scripts are for small things and rapid prototyping. Once when a >> script (

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Eric Butera
On Sun, Jan 18, 2009 at 11:44 AM, Per Jessen wrote: > I think that's at best an example of someone having chosen the wrong > tool. I can easily appreciate the frustration. My own rule-of-thumb - > scripts are for small things and rapid prototyping. Once when a script > (regardless of language) gr

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Robert Cummings
On Sun, 2009-01-18 at 18:10 +, Nathan Rixham wrote: > Jochem Maas wrote: > > Per Jessen schreef: > >> Nathan Rixham wrote: > >> > >>> Per Jessen wrote: > Nathan Rixham wrote: > > >> You can't have your cake and eat it. You can't/shouldn't have > >> strong > >> and loose t

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Nathan Rixham
Stuart wrote: Also, PHP is procedural with OO capabilities due to its history never understood this comment more - wish I'd given it more thought when it stuck out the first time. - cheers stut time4work! -- PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/) To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.ph

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-19 Thread Sancar Saran
Hello guys, It seems most of you very tallended programmers. Could you generate someting like php-- withouth OO just namespaces ? and make 95% of php programmers very happy... this Object Orgy going to blow that language which makes us productive programmers. and My vote goes to Tony...

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:4973b738.3010...@gmail.com... > Tony Marston wrote: >> "Stuart" wrote in message >> news:a5f019de0901181322i2a4cbfaam4d36eff843f42...@mail.gmail.com... >>> 2009/1/18 Tony Marston : In case you have forgotten what this thread is about, the OP gave a >

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Tony Marston wrote: "Stuart" wrote in message news:a5f019de0901181322i2a4cbfaam4d36eff843f42...@mail.gmail.com... 2009/1/18 Tony Marston : In case you have forgotten what this thread is about, the OP gave a list of suggested "improvements" to PHP and asked for opinions. I merely gave my opini

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Stuart" wrote in message news:a5f019de0901181322i2a4cbfaam4d36eff843f42...@mail.gmail.com... > 2009/1/18 Tony Marston : >> In case you have forgotten what this thread is about, the OP gave a list >> of >> suggested "improvements" to PHP and asked for opinions. I merely gave my >> opinion that

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Stuart
2009/1/18 Tony Marston : > In case you have forgotten what this thread is about, the OP gave a list of > suggested "improvements" to PHP and asked for opinions. I merely gave my > opinion that these "improvements" would be a waste of time as they would add > nothing to the language (IMHO, of course

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Tony Marston wrote: "Stuart" wrote in message news:a5f019de0901181015g5e2db21fn2782839ab9648...@mail.gmail.com... 2009/1/18 Tony Marston : "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:497366f5.2030...@gmail.com... Tony Marston wrote: "Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypengu

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:49737051.9080...@gmail.com... Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:497366f5.2030...@gmail.com... Tony Marston wrote: "Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... Wow, Tony, do you thi

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Stuart" wrote in message news:a5f019de0901181015g5e2db21fn2782839ab9648...@mail.gmail.com... > 2009/1/18 Tony Marston : >> >> "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message >> news:497366f5.2030...@gmail.com... >>> Tony Marston wrote: "Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypeng

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:49737051.9080...@gmail.com... > Tony Marston wrote: >> "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message >> news:497366f5.2030...@gmail.com... >>> Tony Marston wrote: "Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... > Wow, Tony, do y

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Stuart
2009/1/18 Tony Marston : > > "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message > news:497366f5.2030...@gmail.com... >> Tony Marston wrote: >>> "Skip Evans" wrote in message >>> news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself with just a

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Jochem Maas wrote: Per Jessen schreef: Nathan Rixham wrote: Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: You can't have your cake and eat it. You can't/shouldn't have strong and loose typing in the same language. In my opinion. "Instead of providing programmers with a black or white choice bet

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:497366f5.2030...@gmail.com... Tony Marston wrote: "Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself with just a bit more civility and in a

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:497354c3.9090...@gmail.com... Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: point is.. Java let's me easily do 70% of what I need to PHP let's me easily do 95% of what I need to I'm curious - can you list what the 25% are? it lacks dynamic

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Jochem Maas
Per Jessen schreef: > Nathan Rixham wrote: > >> Per Jessen wrote: >>> Nathan Rixham wrote: >>> > You can't have your cake and eat it. You can't/shouldn't have > strong > and loose typing in the same language. In my opinion. "Instead of providing programmers with a black or white

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:497366f5.2030...@gmail.com... > Tony Marston wrote: >> "Skip Evans" wrote in message >> news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... >>> Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself >>> with just a bit more civility and in a less

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Per Jessen
Nathan Rixham wrote: > Per Jessen wrote: >> Nathan Rixham wrote: >> You can't have your cake and eat it. You can't/shouldn't have strong and loose typing in the same language. In my opinion. >>> "Instead of providing programmers with a black or white choice >>> between static or

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:497354c3.9090...@gmail.com... > Per Jessen wrote: >> Nathan Rixham wrote: >> >>> point is.. >>> Java let's me easily do 70% of what I need to >>> PHP let's me easily do 95% of what I need to >>> >> >> I'm curious - can you list what the 25% are? > > it lacks

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Tony Marston wrote: "Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself with just a bit more civility and in a less condescending tone? Nathan expressed some thoughts he had, politely, and when out of

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Per Jessen
Nathan Rixham wrote: >>> If we could get that 5% added then PHP would be perfect, not only >>> that but me and the rest of the team at work would be able to make >>> our multi-million pound enterprise projects in PHP instead of java; >>> as would so many others (that can't be a bad thing for PHP)

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: You can't have your cake and eat it. You can't/shouldn't have strong and loose typing in the same language. In my opinion. "Instead of providing programmers with a black or white choice between static or dynamic typing, we should instead strive for soft

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: point is.. Java let's me easily do 70% of what I need to PHP let's me easily do 95% of what I need to I'm curious - can you list what the 25% are? it lacks dynamic typing, the ability to procedural code and its precompiled not interpreted; all in a h

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Per Jessen
Nathan Rixham wrote: >> You can't have your cake and eat it. You can't/shouldn't have strong >> and loose typing in the same language. In my opinion. > > "Instead of providing programmers with a black or white choice between > static or dynamic typing, we should instead strive for softer type >

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Nathan Rixham
Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: Tony Marston wrote: If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. why not? Because your desired functionality is already satisfied by

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Skip Evans
You're right, and as soon as you apologize to Nathan for calling him feeble minded (and promise to adjust your attitude) I will apologize to you. I also think it would be a good idea for you to address the rest of the list and assure everyone you will try to be more polite in the future. Sk

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49733d18.6080...@bigskypenguin.com... >I will be brief. Tony is a dick. To quote your own words: "There's just no need to insult other list members like this." -- Tony Marston http://www.tonymarston.net http://www.radicore.org > Peace & Love, > Skip > > To

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Skip Evans
I will be brief. Tony is a dick. Peace & Love, Skip Tony Marston wrote: "Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself with just a bit more civility and in a less condescending tone? Nathan exp

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Jochem Maas" wrote in message news:4972365b.4060...@iamjochem.com... > Daniel Brown schreef: >> Well, since Nathan asked especially for the opinions of those who >> would disagree with him, I thought all was well >> >> On Sat, Jan 17, 2009 at 13:33, Tony Marston >> wrote: >>> If your f

[PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:49723749.4070...@gmail.com... > Tony Marston wrote: >> "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message >>> >>> a: Optional Static Typing >>> I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type >>> properties, parameters, return types etc (in classes) I know

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Tony Marston
"Skip Evans" wrote in message news:49723137.2010...@bigskypenguin.com... > Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself > with just a bit more civility and in a less condescending tone? > > Nathan expressed some thoughts he had, politely, and when out of his way > to

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Per Jessen
Nathan Rixham wrote: > point is.. > Java let's me easily do 70% of what I need to > PHP let's me easily do 95% of what I need to > I'm curious - can you list what the 25% are? > If we could get that 5% added then PHP would be perfect, not only that > but me and the rest of the team at work woul

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Per Jessen
Nathan Rixham wrote: > Per Jessen wrote: >> Nathan Rixham wrote: >> >>> Tony Marston wrote: If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. >>> why not? >> >> Because your desired functionality is already satis

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-18 Thread Robert Cummings
On Sat, 2009-01-17 at 20:45 +0100, Jochem Maas wrote: > Skip Evans schreef: > > Tony Marston wrote: > > > > It's NOT just so we can blast each other and show off our highly > > dubiously assumed superiority. > > If I was Robbert Cummings I'd nail you on your grammar at this point, > I don't want t

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Stuart
2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : > it's a simple need: if I can type that my variable can only contain an > int, > then I know it's always an int without tonnes of checks to check it > actually > contains an int / is getting set with an int throughout the rest of the > app > (e

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Nathan Rixham
Stuart wrote: 2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : Stuart wrote: 2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message a: Optional Static Typing I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type properties, parameters, return types etc (in classes) I know there

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Stuart
2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : > Stuart wrote: >> >> 2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : >>> >>> Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message > > a: Optional Static Typing > I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type > properties, parameters, return types

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Jochem Maas
Nathan Rixham schreef: > Jochem Maas wrote: >> Nathan Rixham schreef: ... >> try this snippet on for size: >> >> function test(stdClass $o) { var_dump($o); } $o = (object)1; test($o); > > ahh.. you miss the point, request: "I want to type hint that my function > can accept objects of any type, b

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Nathan Rixham
Stuart wrote: 2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: Tony Marston wrote: If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. why not? Because your desired functionality is already satisfied by

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Nathan Rixham
Stuart wrote: 2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message a: Optional Static Typing I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type properties, parameters, return types etc (in classes) I know there is type hinting but it's just not enough

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Stuart
2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : > Per Jessen wrote: >> >> Nathan Rixham wrote: >> >>> Tony Marston wrote: If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. >>> >>> why not? >> >> Because your desired functionality is

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Stuart
2009/1/17 Nathan Rixham : > Tony Marston wrote: >> >> "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message >>> >>> a: Optional Static Typing >>> I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type >>> properties, parameters, return types etc (in classes) I know there is type >>> hinting but it's just no

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Nathan Rixham
Jochem Maas wrote: Nathan Rixham schreef: Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message a: Optional Static Typing I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type properties, parameters, return types etc (in classes) I know there is type hinting but it's just not enoug

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Nathan Rixham
Per Jessen wrote: Nathan Rixham wrote: Tony Marston wrote: If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. why not? Because your desired functionality is already satisfied by other programming languages. PHP is an

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Jochem Maas
Nathan Rixham schreef: > Tony Marston wrote: >> "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message >>> >>> a: Optional Static Typing >>> I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type >>> properties, parameters, return types etc (in classes) I know there is >>> type hinting but it's just not enou

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Per Jessen
Nathan Rixham wrote: > Tony Marston wrote: >> >> If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use >> PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. > > why not? Because your desired functionality is already satisfied by other programming languages. PHP is an interp

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Nathan Rixham
Per Jessen wrote: Tony Marston wrote: If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. +1 I do.. mainly Java when I need it (can you tell) point is.. Java let's me easily do 70% of what I need to PHP let's me easil

[PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Nathan Rixham
Tony Marston wrote: "Nathan Rixham" wrote in message a: Optional Static Typing I'm finding an ever increasingly need to be able to staticly type properties, parameters, return types etc (in classes) I know there is type hinting but it's just not enough to do what one needs. Additionally sup

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Eric Butera
On Sat, Jan 17, 2009 at 2:42 PM, Daniel Brown wrote: >Well, since Nathan asked especially for the opinions of those who > would disagree with him, I thought all was well > > On Sat, Jan 17, 2009 at 13:33, Tony Marston > wrote: >> >> If your feeble brain can't handle the differences >> the

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Per Jessen
Tony Marston wrote: > If you really *need* to used a staticly typed language then don't use > PHP, and don't try to change PHP to match your needs. +1 /Per Jessen, Zürich -- PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/) To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Jochem Maas
Daniel Brown schreef: > Well, since Nathan asked especially for the opinions of those who > would disagree with him, I thought all was well > > On Sat, Jan 17, 2009 at 13:33, Tony Marston > wrote: >> If your feeble brain can't handle the differences >> then I suggest you stick with your p

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Jochem Maas
Skip Evans schreef: > Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself > with just a bit more civility and in a less condescending tone? going on past experience ... I doubt it. > Nathan expressed some thoughts he had, politely, and when out of his way > to come across in a

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Daniel Brown
Well, since Nathan asked especially for the opinions of those who would disagree with him, I thought all was well On Sat, Jan 17, 2009 at 13:33, Tony Marston wrote: > > If your feeble brain can't handle the differences > then I suggest you stick with your previous language and LEAVE PHP A

Re: [PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Skip Evans
Wow, Tony, do you think in the future you could try to express yourself with just a bit more civility and in a less condescending tone? Nathan expressed some thoughts he had, politely, and when out of his way to come across in a non-critical and non-confrontational manner. Tony Marston wrot

[PHP] Re: Opinions / Votes Needed

2009-01-17 Thread Tony Marston
"Nathan Rixham" wrote in message news:88.0b.41390.8f512...@pb1.pair.com... > Afternoon all, > > I'd love to get some votes from my fellow developers on the following, and > indeed some opinions (especially from those who disagree). > > Recently I've been running in to a lot of frustrations with