Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
Oops, of course, I *meant* to say: "In general, you can't expect a RTSP *server* to work if it's behind a NAT." -- Ross Finlayson Live Networks, Inc. http://www.live555.com/ ___ live-devel mailing list live-devel@lists.live555.com http://lists.live555.

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
>The "server" doesn't have a public IP. >It is behind a NAT (behind a consumer DSL modem) and doesn't even know >what it is NATed to. Yes, that's the problem. In general, you can't expect a RTSP sorry to work if it's behind a NAT. The IETF is working on overcoming this, but for now that's just

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Bill Dolson
Ross, Hope you don't mind if I don't bottom post. This seems to be a cardinal sin on FFmpeg-devel and vlc-devel. Anyway thanks for your help. > No, your NAT is making this way too complicated! Agreed. but we're (I'm) stuck with it. Not even mine, another vendor I'm trying to integrate with.

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
>I think you're making this way too complicated. No, your NAT is making this way too complicated! > Simple question: As >per the RFC, should the RTCP RRs go to the IP in the original rtsp://... >or to the IP reported as the Content-Base The latter. > (due to the horrible, nasty, >abominab

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Bill Dolson
Ross Finlayson wrote: >> > They should be getting sent to whichever server IP address was >>> specified in the "rtsp://" URL, or - if a server domain name was >>> specified instead - whatever IP address that domain name resolved to >>> when it was looked up (via DNS). >>> >>> RTSP/RTP cannot r

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
> > They should be getting sent to whichever server IP address was >> specified in the "rtsp://" URL, or - if a server domain name was >> specified instead - whatever IP address that domain name resolved to >> when it was looked up (via DNS). >> >> RTSP/RTP cannot reliably be expected to work

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Bill Dolson
Ross Finlayson wrote: >> The RTCP RRs are being sent, but apparently to the un-NATed local >> network address of the server > > They should be getting sent to whichever server IP address was > specified in the "rtsp://" URL, or - if a server domain name was > specified instead - whatever IP addr

Re: [Live-devel] Vatican CTV live stream

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
Hi, The Vatican CTV live stream - rtsp://212.77.7.133:80/h264lan.sdp does not work with openRTSP. On the vatican homepage there is a note, that VLC media player should play them, but it does not. Both "openRTSP" and "VLC" (and "QuickTime Player") play the stream OK for me. Perhaps you're stuc

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
>The RTCP RRs are being sent, but apparently to the un-NATed local >network address of the server They should be getting sent to whichever server IP address was specified in the "rtsp://" URL, or - if a server domain name was specified instead - whatever IP address that domain name resolved to

Re: [Live-devel] Just in case the server responses nothing

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
This is a know problem with the current implementation of "RTSPClient". It should be doing asynchronous socket reads (within the event loop), rather than a (potentially blocking) synchronous read. Fixing this is on my 'to do' list. In the meantime, your immediate priority should be to figure

Re: [Live-devel] Input Buffer Consumed

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
I'm new to LiveMedia library and I am experimented with it under Windows OS. I have found in the file ByteStreamFileSource.cpp the code that synchronously read the source buffer from a file. I need to know however when the library will have finished of using the buffer. Note that the buffer t

[Live-devel] Vatican CTV live stream

2007-12-10 Thread double
Hi, The Vatican CTV live stream - rtsp://212.77.7.133:80/h264lan.sdp does not work with openRTSP. On the vatican homepage there is a note, that VLC media player should play them, but it does not. Is this a problem of live555? Currently, the stream should be on. Thank you very much Markus Doppe

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Bill Dolson
Bill Dolson wrote: > Bill Dolson wrote: >> Hi, >> >> Weird one. Running wis-streamer from composite video >> >> wis-streaner -r 64000 -na >> >> Using VLC 0.8.6d Windows running on the same LAN as the server will play >> the stream all day. >> >> Using the same VLC version Windows or Linux (el5) f

Re: [Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Bill Dolson
Bill Dolson wrote: > Hi, > > Weird one. Running wis-streamer from composite video > > wis-streaner -r 64000 -na > > Using VLC 0.8.6d Windows running on the same LAN as the server will play > the stream all day. > > Using the same VLC version Windows or Linux (el5) from anywhere on the > Inte

[Live-devel] Problem with VLC and wis-streamer

2007-12-10 Thread Bill Dolson
Hi, Weird one. Running wis-streamer from composite video wis-streaner -r 64000 -na Using VLC 0.8.6d Windows running on the same LAN as the server will play the stream all day. Using the same VLC version Windows or Linux (el5) from anywhere on the Internet playback freezes after approx 45 sec

[Live-devel] Input Buffer Consumed

2007-12-10 Thread Guy Bonneau
Hello, I'm new to LiveMedia library and I am experimented with it under Windows OS. I have found in the file ByteStreamFileSource.cpp the code that synchronously read the source buffer from a file. I need to know however when the library will have finished of using the buffer. Is there some fee

[Live-devel] Just in case the server responses nothing

2007-12-10 Thread Brain Lai
Dear Sir: When I try to connect AXIS IP camera several times(one to many, no regular pattern), the RTSPClient::describeURL() never retruns. After doing some source tracing, I find that it is blocked in readSocket() in RTSPClient::getResponse1(). This is because the readSocket() calls blockUntilRea

Re: [Live-devel] question: possibility to extend the code to support 3g video streaming

2007-12-10 Thread Ross Finlayson
> i was wondering is it possible to extend the source code posted in >live555 to support 3G video streaming ? We already support streaming all of the audio and video codecs (and protocols) used by so-called '3G' clients. (However, we don't yet support streaming from pre-recorded MPEG-4-format

[Live-devel] Howto create MPEG Transport Stream

2007-12-10 Thread Swapnil Jain
Hi, I have mp4 video, how do i convert it to transport stream so that i can play it on amino stb Swapnil Jain Indore ___ live-devel mailing list live-devel@lists.live555.com http://lists.live555.com/mailman/listinfo/live-devel

[Live-devel] question: possibility to extend the code to support 3g video streaming

2007-12-10 Thread kok lim Tan
hi , I am new to this forum. i am an electronic and electrical student and currently i am doing my final year project on 3G live video streaming from a network camera. i was wondering is it possible to extend the source code posted in live555 to support 3G video streaming ? the only hardware i h