Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-15 Thread Kanak Biscuitwala
Hi, I'm a committer/PMC member for Apache Helix, and we've already done some of the work integrating with systems like YARN (pretty much ready to go) and Mesos (about 1/3 of the way there). For some background, Helix separates cluster management logic from application logic by modeling an appli

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-14 Thread Steve Loughran
On 14 April 2014 04:43, Andreas Neumann wrote: > I'd like to comment on what has been said about Twill. > > >> Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code packaged as a JAR > with > >> an executor method > > The goal of Twill is much broader than to support writing new code. Its > goal i

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-14 Thread Steve Loughran
On 12 April 2014 23:38, Roman Shaposhnik wrote: > On Sat, Apr 12, 2014 at 11:58 AM, Andrew Purtell > wrote: > >> > The reason I ask is I'm wondering how Slider differentiates from > projects > >> > like Apache Twill or Apache Bigtop that are already existing vehicles > for > >> > achieving the a

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-13 Thread Andreas Neumann
I'd like to comment on what has been said about Twill. >> Twill: handles all the AM logic for running new code packaged as a JAR with >> an executor method The goal of Twill is much broader than to support writing new code. Its goal is to ease the development and deployment of any distributed ser

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-12 Thread Roman Shaposhnik
On Sat, Apr 12, 2014 at 11:58 AM, Andrew Purtell wrote: >> > The reason I ask is I'm wondering how Slider differentiates from projects >> > like Apache Twill or Apache Bigtop that are already existing vehicles for >> > achieving the aims discussed in the Slider proposal. >> >> >> Twill: handles al

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-12 Thread Andrew Purtell
On Sat, Apr 12, 2014 at 3:27 AM, Steve Loughran wrote: > On 10 April 2014 16:28, Andrew Purtell wrote: > > > Hi Steve, > > > > Does Slider target the deployment and management of components/projects > in > > the Hadoop project itself? Not just the ecosystem examples mentioned in > the > > proposa

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-12 Thread Steve Loughran
On 10 April 2014 16:28, Andrew Purtell wrote: > Hi Steve, > > Does Slider target the deployment and management of components/projects in > the Hadoop project itself? Not just the ecosystem examples mentioned in the > proposal? I don't see this mentioned in the proposal. > no. That said, some of

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-10 Thread Andrew Purtell
Hi Steve, Does Slider target the deployment and management of components/projects in the Hadoop project itself? Not just the ecosystem examples mentioned in the proposal? I don't see this mentioned in the proposal. The reason I ask is I'm wondering how Slider differentiates from projects like Apa

Re: Slider Proposal

2014-04-02 Thread Arun C. Murthy
Looks great, thanks for the update Steve. Arun > On Mar 31, 2014, at 8:49 PM, Steve Loughran wrote: > > Hi > > > For people wondering what's been happening with that Hoya proposal, I've > got a successor proposal up for discussion. > > > https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/SliderProposal >