Re: Differences in voting rules between Apache Maturity Model and Incubator Default Project Guidelines

On Thu, Mar 7, 2019 at 5:30 AM Christofer Dutz wrote: >... > Not quite sure which rules should be applied. > The Incubator rules, clearly. The "maturity model" is simply a web page produced by ComDev. It has zero application to the Incubator, or to the Foundation. Regards, -g

Differences in voting rules between Apache Maturity Model and Incubator Default Project Guidelines

. However the Incubator Default Project Guidelines [2] suggest code changes are “lazy consensus” and stuff like Comitter, PMC, Chai changes are “Consensus approval” which is described as: Consensus approval requires 3 binding<https://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html#binding-votes&

Re: Default project guidelines

Hi, > Thank you for such a short and informative article. I'll definitely link to > it from Apache Ignite wiki space. > > What do you think about including a link to > http://community.apache.org/newcommitter.html This page also gives a good > level of understanding what should and should not a

Re: Default project guidelines

Hi Justin, Thank you for such a short and informative article. I'll definitely link to it from Apache Ignite wiki space. What do you think about including a link to http://community.apache.org/newcommitter.html This page also gives a good level of understanding what should and should not a poten

Re: Default project guidelines

Hi, [1] being this link https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/DefaultProjectGuidelines sorry I forgot to add it in the last email. Thanks, Justin

Re: Default project guidelines

Hi, So does anyone have anything to add to this [1] before I post this to the board list as a suggestion for them to considered? Thanks, Justin - To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional co

Re: Default project guidelines

Hi, Little off topic but I’ll bite. The context was that this is about giving a default set of rules to podlings so that they don’t copy and past other projects guidelines that are not in line with the Apache Way. > In the case of on- and off-boarding members of the privileged ranks (which > is

Re: Default project guidelines

Consensus is a 'potential' outcome, and more often than not regarded as the 'must have'y rule in projects of the ASF: we must have consensus on who gets privileges to commit, to get PMC privileges... Achieving consensus for each and every issue arising in a project (whether it is in the incubator,

Re: Default project guidelines

Hi, > There is a lot of confusion if the approval should be censuses or majority > for adding or removing people in the various projects guidelines/bylaws. > Consensus seem more common so I went with that - that may be wrong. Our docs are not clear on this either [1] states that consensus votin

Default project guidelines

Hi, There been some discussion on bylaws/guidelines recently and it was suggest that the IPMC document a default set for projects to use. So I’ve come up with a default set of guidelines [1] using links to existing content when I could find it. I tried to make it as minimal as possible. Feedba