Re: AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-21 Thread Adam Peller
Craig, Sam addressed the social engineering viewpoint; I'd like to talk about the software side: > Craig McClanahan wrote: >From a software engineering viewpoint, focusing on a single tool as a >delivery vehicle will tend to bias architectural and implementation >decisions towards what is easy to

Re: AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-21 Thread Adam Peller
JAX Toolkit Framework Proposal On Tue, 2005-12-20 at 23:18 -0500, Adam Peller wrote: > > 2) The other subproject is Z

Re: AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-20 Thread Adam Peller
u tell me if you considered proposing this to the Eclipse > Foundation? > >> > >>Since this project appears to have far stronger dependencies on > >>Eclipse Foundation projects rather than anything from Apache, can you > >>tell me why you think bringing this project he

Re: AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-20 Thread Adam Peller
Cliff, Sam has gone through the rationale on community, licensing, etc. On a technical level, I'd like to point out that while the tools subproject does use Eclipse and the WebTools project, it attempts to do so through limited, well-known APIs. We've been working with the Eclipse team on def

Re: AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-20 Thread Adam Peller
Hey Sanjiva! Yeah, it's been a while. I've been trying to follow your projects and blogs over the years. Sounds like all is going well. No secret agendas here :) Happy to answer. >So this may not be an appropriate part of the discussion for deciding >whether to accept this for incubation or n

Re: AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-20 Thread Adam Peller
Sylvain - Sylvain Wallez wrote: >So the questions are: >- is the ASF the place for Eclipse extensions? I don't deny the ability >to _existing_ project to host their tooling, but this isn't the case here. The framework is composed of tools that happen to use Eclipse for a runtime, much like Java-b

Re: AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-20 Thread Adam Peller
; Paul Fremantle > VP/Technology, WSO2 and OASIS WS-RX TC Co-chair > > http://bloglines.com/blog/paulfremantle > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > "Oxygenating the Web Service Platform", www.wso2.com > > On 12/20/05, Adam Peller <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > >

AJAX Toolkit Framework Proposal

2005-12-20 Thread Adam Peller
AJAXTK (AJAXTK) 4. Identify the initial set of committers: * Craig Becker * Leugim Bustelo * Andrew Clark * Conrad Damon * Ross Dargahi * Becky Gibson * Javier Pedemonte * Adam Peller * Roland Schemers * Donald Sedota * Parag Shah * Greg Solovyev 5. I