Re: [gdal-dev] CSharp bindings queued for removal (was Re: GDAL CSharp bindings maintainers/contributors listening... ?)

2025-02-17 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
{apologies for the late response - add your preferred rif on "I was busy" excuses} The PDAL approach is much easier (speaking as the de facto C# maintainer for PDAL and MDAL). However - it is a real "I would not start from here" issue (to quote our Irish cousins). I cannot see the communities in

Re: [gdal-dev] Missing GDALMemDataset , GDALDatasetRasterIOEx , VSIMem when GDAL is built with CSHARP Bindings

2025-01-31 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
see Line 751 ++ for the list of build targets On Fri, 31 Jan 2025 at 13:38, Paul Harwood wrote: > https://github.com/OSGeo/gdal/blob/master/swig/csharp/CMakeLists.txt > > On Fri, 31 Jan 2025 at 13:36, Parveen Sharma > wrote: > >> Thanks >> >> Could you please point me to the relevant scripts? >

Re: [gdal-dev] Missing GDALMemDataset , GDALDatasetRasterIOEx , VSIMem when GDAL is built with CSHARP Bindings

2025-01-31 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
https://github.com/OSGeo/gdal/blob/master/swig/csharp/CMakeLists.txt On Fri, 31 Jan 2025 at 13:36, Parveen Sharma wrote: > Thanks > > Could you please point me to the relevant scripts? > -- > *From:* Paul Harwood > *Sent:* Friday, January 31, 2025 9:31 PM > *To:* Par

Re: [gdal-dev] Missing GDALMemDataset , GDALDatasetRasterIOEx , VSIMem when GDAL is built with CSHARP Bindings

2025-01-31 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
I have checked and the three .csproj projects that you listed are NOT currently being build by the build scripts - because they are not needed for the test scripts. You will need to build them yourself. On Fri, 31 Jan 2025 at 13:23, Paul Harwood wrote: > The first question that I would ask is wh

Re: [gdal-dev] Missing GDALMemDataset , GDALDatasetRasterIOEx , VSIMem when GDAL is built with CSHARP Bindings

2025-01-31 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
The first question that I would ask is what are you trying to achieve? DBUILD_APPS=ON will build the standard GDAL apps but does not affect the C# trial apps. I think this is the default anyway DBUILD_CSHARP_BINDINGS=ON will build the c# bindings and the c# trial apps. If that is what you are try

Re: [gdal-dev] CSharp bindings queued for removal (was Re: GDAL CSharp bindings maintainers/contributors listening... ?)

2025-01-31 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
The problem about "moving" the bindings is going to be that all of the SWIG definitions for all bindings are intimately wound together. It would be a lot of work for little gain. The danger of the "surveys and feedback" driven approach, which I felt like saying at the time of the last survey but i

Re: [gdal-dev] CSharp bindings queued for removal (was Re: GDAL CSharp bindings maintainers/contributors listening... ?)

2025-01-29 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
al-dev] C# > bindings compilation > <https://www.mail-archive.com/gdal-dev@lists.osgeo.org/msg35936.html> > from 2021. > > > > -Jukka Rahkonen- > > > > *Lähettäjä:* gdal-dev *Puolesta *Paul > Harwood via gdal-dev > *Lähetetty:* keskiviikko 29. tammikuuta 2025 1

Re: [gdal-dev] CSharp bindings queued for removal (was Re: GDAL CSharp bindings maintainers/contributors listening... ?)

2025-01-29 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
It seems to be a hyper aggressive move to go from a highly technical question about UTF-8 to "remove C# totally". If the question is "We need a named maintainer for C# or we remove it" then I will step forward since I have an app that depends on it. However, I don't feel competent enough in SWIG t

Re: [gdal-dev] adding points to geometries

2025-01-26 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
Create a new geometry, iterate through each segment of the old geometry if the segment does not intersect the equator, add that segment to the new geometry, else, use the intersection point to create two segments in the new geometry. On Sun, 26 Jan 2025 at 12:49, Javier Jimenez Shaw wrote: > Th

Re: [gdal-dev] adding points to geometries

2025-01-26 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
I would have thought : create a linesegment that is the equator and perform an intersection between that linesegment and the target geometry to identify the point in question and then create a new geometry with the new point, or something like that. I am not sure what it would mean to add a point

Re: [gdal-dev] Is it possible to write custom CRS WKTs within a GeoTiff?

2025-01-09 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
"If you can sacrifice the ellipsoidal height axis to avoid using a > Projected 3D CRS, which is a bit of a geodetic dubious object (don't ask me > more, but minds more enlightned than me question the soundness of using an > ellipsoidal heights with a projected CRS)” > > > I won’t ask you more :) bu

Re: [gdal-dev] Would it be a good idea have a users list?

2024-11-07 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
My tuppence worth (yes - a Britishism) just as a user and not a stakeholder ... I would say that the real-life experience is likely to be that no one knows or agrees what message should be on what list, people will post "on the wrong list" and be asked to repost, everyone will end up on both lists

Re: [gdal-dev] Proposed RFC 8 amendment regarding (prohibited use of) generative AI tools

2024-10-08 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
While I am at it - the stuff about "changes that are not subject to copyright law" is meaningless - copyright applies to content and not to changes and I doubt there is any content on GDAL that is NOT subject to copyright law. I would humbly suggest that the question is more about whether "correct

Re: [gdal-dev] Proposed RFC 8 amendment regarding (prohibited use of) generative AI tools

2024-10-08 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
IANAL - however I have looked at a lot of these things in my time. The phrase "use of generative AI tools to contribute copyrighted material is prohibited" is ambiguous (and actually nugatory): - for clarity - it should say that it is prohibited to use such tools to contribute *to the project* ot

Re: [gdal-dev] Reading interpolated values on DSM

2024-04-24 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
If you want to do it in QGIS ... https://plugins.qgis.org/plugins/rasterinterpolation/ On Wed, 24 Apr 2024, 09:33 Javier Jimenez Shaw via gdal-dev, < gdal-dev@lists.osgeo.org> wrote: > Hi > > I would like to read in QGIS or GDAL an interpolated value in a DSM (well, > actually it is a geoid mode

[gdal-dev] GDAL DATA PATH - test

2024-04-15 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
I have an interesting little problem. I want to write (in the code using the API - not as a test script - actually in C#) a command that will fail if the GDAL data path is set incorrectly. I am having difficulty finding a command that will fail if the path is incorrect. I thought that some of th

Re: [gdal-dev] How to publish a C# GDAL project to Linux?

2024-01-09 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
{ "emoji": "😀", "version": 1 }___ gdal-dev mailing list gdal-dev@lists.osgeo.org https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/gdal-dev

Re: [gdal-dev] How to publish a C# GDAL project to Linux?

2024-01-09 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
Also responded on SO On Tue, 9 Jan 2024 at 15:57, George Watson via gdal-dev < gdal-dev@lists.osgeo.org> wrote: > Answered on SO (no pun intended). > > George K. Watson > Stuff-doer > Maxar > > On 01/09/2024 8:10 AM MST Vedran Mornar via gdal-dev < > gdal-dev@lists.osgeo.org> wrote: > > > > Hi, >

Re: [gdal-dev] Spatial references and geometry operations

2023-09-29 Thread Paul Harwood via gdal-dev
As a very general response, you probably need to differentiate between two possible questions that you are asking, either: 1 Does the operation fail with an error, or 2 Is the result correct or meaningful? I don't know about 1). My guess and experience is that, in most cases, it won't fail. Howe