Re: [gdal-dev] New JPEG 2000 Driver

2021-03-01 Thread Andrew C Aitchison
On Mon, 1 Mar 2021, Greg Troxel wrote: I also was unclear on the optional driver situation. Certainly if drivers can link with proprietary libraries, there is absolutely no reason to object to a driver because it links so an AGPL3 library. I believe that drivers with non-MIT licenses shouldn't

Re: [gdal-dev] New JPEG 2000 Driver

2021-03-01 Thread Greg Troxel
Having ranted earlier about the use of AGPL3 to sell proprietary licenses, I'd like to say that I'm glad to hear the new library is "righteous AGPL3" instead of "subversive AGPL3". I also was unclear on the optional driver situation. Certainly if drivers can link with proprietary libraries, ther

Re: [gdal-dev] Motion: adopt RFC79: Listing of Service Providers on GDAL website

2021-03-01 Thread Even Rouault
Hi > I motion to adopt RFC79: Listing of Service Providers on GDAL website: > https://github.com/OSGeo/gdal/pull/3473 > > Starting with my +1 I declare this motion passed with +1 from PSC members MateuszL, KurtS, JukkaR, DanielM and myself. Best regards, Even -- http://www.spatialys.com __

Re: [gdal-dev] New JPEG 2000 Driver

2021-03-01 Thread Aaron Boxer
Hi Jukka, Thanks, makes a lot of sense. My comments about removing proprietary drivers weren't meant as a provocation, I'm sorry you received it that way. Just a thought experiment to explore possible inconsistency of keeping proprietary drivers while pushing back on GPL drivers. But your explana

Re: [gdal-dev] New JPEG 2000 Driver

2021-03-01 Thread jratike80
Hi, In my opinion it is GDAL's mandate to favor projects that use the same type of license than GDAL itself. Both proprietary and more copy-left licenses makes it a bit harder to handle the whole system. Individual developers may have their own opinions about what licensing model is the best when

Re: [gdal-dev] New JPEG 2000 Driver

2021-03-01 Thread Aaron Boxer
Hi Brad, Definitely makes for an interesting discussion. A few questions to ponder: Is it GDAL's mandate to encourage projects with permissive licenses and to, shall we say, discourage those with copy-left licenses ? This is how Google and Apple operate, but they are for-profit corporations who

[gdal-dev] Merge the GeoJSON files

2021-03-01 Thread MRRAJESH
Hi, I have two GeoJSON files. One is having features A and B, another one is having Features B and C. In these two files Feature B is common ( same attributes and same geometry). Now I want to merge these two GeoJSON files into either a single GoeJSON file or a GPKG file. But the Output file shou