Re: feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-11 Thread James Tauber
As of r20, django-atompub now includes a `LegacySyndicationFeed` class (in atom.py) which implements the same signature for `__init__` and `add_item` as django's existing `SyndicationFeed` does but under the covers is a new `AtomFeed`. I haven't fully tested it but I'm hoping this addresses

Re: feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-10 Thread James Tauber
On 10/08/2007, at 9:27 AM, Rob Hudson wrote: > I know the basics of what Atom is and what AtomPub is (but not quite > clear on where REST and full AtomPub differ or relate -- they sound > like they have a lot of overlap where maybe REST is at the HTTP level > and AtomPub is more on implementation

Re: feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-10 Thread Rob Hudson
I've been watching the development with interest. I'm probably your user #1 with curiosity that might lead to user #2. I know the basics of what Atom is and what AtomPub is (but not quite clear on where REST and full AtomPub differ or relate -- they sound like they have a lot of overlap where may

Re: feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-09 Thread James Tauber
> It's gonna be tricky figuring out the "right" way to handle this, > especially because "right" is going to differ greatly depending on > audience. There are also a number of difference scenarios: 1. a user has written a Feed using either RSS or the existing Atom1 and it meets their needs. 2.

Re: feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-09 Thread Jacob Kaplan-Moss
On 8/9/07, James Tauber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > By "replace" I mean in usage not in distribution. I full expect the > existing classes with stay (with Atom1Feed perhaps deprecated). I > consider atom.py an *additional* module, not a replacement module. By > "replace" I merely meant that someo

Re: feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-09 Thread James Tauber
On 09/08/2007, at 7:58 AM, Malcolm Tredinnick wrote: > Are you looking for feedback in general (as in "is anybody using it?", > a.k.a. "is this microphone on?") or as a resolution for #3569 and > inclusion in contrib/syndication? I think there is still some polishing to do for including in contri

Re: feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-09 Thread Malcolm Tredinnick
Hi James, On Thu, 2007-08-09 at 04:31 -0400, James Tauber wrote: > Any feedback on my full atom feed support > > http://code.google.com/p/django-atompub/ > > ? Are you looking for feedback in general (as in "is anybody using it?", a.k.a. "is this microphone on?") or as a resolution for #3569 a

feedback on full atom feed support

2007-08-09 Thread James Tauber
Any feedback on my full atom feed support http://code.google.com/p/django-atompub/ ? atom.py is the relevant module and it, in affect, replaces use of django.contrib.syndication.feeds.Feed, django.utils.feedgenerator.SyndicationFeed and django.utils.feedgenerator.Atom1Feed This is for ti