Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-18 Thread Russell Keith-Magee
On Tue, Oct 19, 2010 at 10:29 AM, Will Hardy wrote: > Whilst I agree that messing with contrib.auth is likely to break > something and create more work, I think it would be good for Django if > everyone in the Django community went and needlessly ported their real > world views to CBV, to expose a

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-18 Thread Will Hardy
Whilst I agree that messing with contrib.auth is likely to break something and create more work, I think it would be good for Django if everyone in the Django community went and needlessly ported their real world views to CBV, to expose any deficiencies in the framework before release. Even if the

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-18 Thread Jacob Kaplan-Moss
2010/10/18 Łukasz Rekucki : > Somehow related, I was wondering today, would it be a good idea to try > to rewrite contrib.auth views in terms of CBV, so that other parts of > Django could benefit. I'm not particularly clear on what other parts would benefit -- fill me in? In general, I frown on r

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-18 Thread Łukasz Rekucki
On 19 October 2010 01:17, Gabriel Hurley wrote: > I got my first real taste of the new API today by thoroughly proofing > the docs for class-based views. I just wanted to say that there's some > great stuff in there, and I give a big thanks to everyone who > contributed! I'm really looking forward

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-18 Thread Gabriel Hurley
I got my first real taste of the new API today by thoroughly proofing the docs for class-based views. I just wanted to say that there's some great stuff in there, and I give a big thanks to everyone who contributed! I'm really looking forward to using the new class-based views ASAP. Thanks! -