Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-16 Thread Russell Keith-Magee
On Sunday, October 17, 2010, Yo-Yo Ma wrote: > Gabriel > > You don't have to go to thesaurus.com with the intention of generating > a more formidable argument. I was merely offering my opinion. Playing > devil's advocate should be regarded as counter constructive. If I see > a man about to throw a

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-16 Thread Michael
> I was merely offering my opinion. Playing > devil's advocate should[n't] be regarded as counter constructive. But it is, playing devil's advocate is by definition a destructive position. There's nothing particularly wrong with that in general, but it's a little late in the class-based-views dis

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-16 Thread Yo-Yo Ma
Typo (on iPhone): should read, "...devil's advocate shouldn't be..." On Oct 16, 2:24 pm, Yo-Yo Ma wrote: > Gabriel > > You don't have to go to thesaurus.com with the intention of generating > a more formidable argument. I was merely offering my opinion. Playing > devil's advocate should be regard

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-16 Thread Yo-Yo Ma
Gabriel You don't have to go to thesaurus.com with the intention of generating a more formidable argument. I was merely offering my opinion. Playing devil's advocate should be regarded as counter constructive. If I see a man about to throw an egg at an otherwise clean wall, I don't need to offer h

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-16 Thread Brian Neal
On Oct 16, 2:34 am, Gabriel Hurley wrote: > > What do you call this. I don't see how any software developer could > > consider constructive criticism as anything other than helping out. > > You've posted three messages in this thread, but none of them seem > "constructive" to me. You've pointed ou

Re: #6375 -- Class Based Views: Opinions on commit plan

2010-10-16 Thread Gabriel Hurley
> What do you call this. I don't see how any software developer could > consider constructive criticism as anything other than helping out. You've posted three messages in this thread, but none of them seem "constructive" to me. You've pointed out areas of disagreement and used inflammatory hyperb