Re: [Development] Commit policies and the Qt 5 alpha

2012-03-19 Thread lars.knoll
On 3/19/12 9:19 AM, "ext Thorbjørn Martsum" wrote: >Hi Lars > >You are the boss :) - and I am not disagreeing that this should happen >rather sooner then later (it is actually happening very late if the final >release plan still says june), >but I however think it would be better (in the future)

Re: [Development] Commit policies and the Qt 5 alpha

2012-03-19 Thread Thiago Macieira
On segunda-feira, 19 de março de 2012 09.19.56, Thorbjørn Martsum wrote: > but I however think it would be better (in the future) to announce such an > api soft freeze a few days before it happens. Please note that: 1) the announcement didn't change much. You were already supposed to be following

Re: [Development] Commit policies and the Qt 5 alpha

2012-03-19 Thread Thorbjørn Martsum
Hi Lars You are the boss :) - and I am not disagreeing that this should happen rather sooner then later (it is actually happening very late if the final release plan still says june), but I however think it would be better (in the future) to announce such an api soft freeze a few days before it ha

Re: [Development] Commit policies and the Qt 5 alpha

2012-03-18 Thread lars.knoll
On 3/18/12 9:05 PM, "ext Thiago Macieira" wrote: >On domingo, 18 de março de 2012 19.55.53, lars.kn...@nokia.com wrote: >> * No more source incompatible changes to features/API that are new in Qt >> 5, unless approved by the module's maintainer after a discussion on the >> mailing list > >Does th

Re: [Development] Commit policies and the Qt 5 alpha

2012-03-18 Thread Thiago Macieira
On domingo, 18 de março de 2012 19.55.53, lars.kn...@nokia.com wrote: > * No more source incompatible changes to features/API that are new in Qt > 5, unless approved by the module's maintainer after a discussion on the > mailing list Does this include source-incompatible changes that restore compa

[Development] Commit policies and the Qt 5 alpha

2012-03-18 Thread lars.knoll
Hi everybody, there are quite a few people meeting up in Oslo this week, and we'll try to finish up the Qt 5 alpha there. For this reason I'd like everybody to restrain themselves in what they submit to the master branch. The main focus needs to be to get the alpha, so please focus on staging only