Re: SharingWebappClassLoader proposal

2010-08-11 Thread Lohner Roland
Dear Mark, Rainer, Konstantin, Sylvain, Thank you for your answers. (and for Tomcat ;-) Regards, R. 2010/8/5 Sylvain Laurent > > I see 2 options for your case : > > - either use JRebel which allows to reload classes even in jars that would be > the common or shared classloaded (I use it all t

Re: SharingWebappClassLoader proposal

2010-08-05 Thread Sylvain Laurent
I see 2 options for your case : - either use JRebel which allows to reload classes even in jars that would be the common or shared classloaded (I use it all the times, it's fabulous and pays for itself very quickly) - or try JBoss which has a Unified Class Loader, and as far as I understood it,

Re: SharingWebappClassLoader proposal

2010-08-05 Thread Lohner Roland
Dear Mark, Rainer, Konstantin, Thank you for your fast and detailed answers. You are right, the proposal is erroneous. However my intention was not to give an excellent implementation solving the problem, but to start a conversation about it and to provide a 0th approach, which can be reworked, r

Re: SharingWebappClassLoader proposal

2010-08-03 Thread Konstantin Kolinko
2010/8/3 Lohner Roland : > Dear Developers, > > I am writing about a proposal for a new feature in Tomcat. > (...) > so the only solution at the > moment is to use a J2EE container and deploy an enterprise module which > causes unnecessary overheat. I think the following should work: 1. Separat

Re: SharingWebappClassLoader proposal

2010-08-03 Thread Rainer Jung
Hi Roland, On 03.08.2010 16:36, Mark Thomas wrote: On 03/08/2010 15:19, Lohner Roland wrote: Dear Developers, I recommend the consideration of the acceptance of this proposal and I am also very curious of your opinion. I don't see this providing any features over and above the shared class

Re: SharingWebappClassLoader proposal

2010-08-03 Thread Mark Thomas
On 03/08/2010 15:19, Lohner Roland wrote: > Dear Developers, I recommend the consideration of the acceptance of this > proposal and I am also very curious of your opinion. I don't see this providing any features over and above the shared class loader that is already available. The proposal appear

SharingWebappClassLoader proposal

2010-08-03 Thread Lohner Roland
Dear Developers, I am writing about a proposal for a new feature in Tomcat. The need itself has been created in our software team, but it is not a special need to our team. It is a basic one, which probably lots of users could benefit from. The situation is the following. We are doing dist