Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-23 Thread Remy Maucherat
On Mon, 2008-09-22 at 22:54 +0100, Mark Thomas wrote: > This is currently being raised with the EG for clarification. I'll let > people know when I receive a response. It should be ~3 weeks max. Ok, cool :) Rémy - To unsubscri

Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-22 Thread Mark Thomas
This is currently being raised with the EG for clarification. I'll let people know when I receive a response. It should be ~3 weeks max. Mark - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PR

Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-19 Thread Mark Thomas
Konstantin Kolinko wrote: > Mark, > > I tend to agree with your reading of the EBNF grammar there, but I think that > the grammar is wrong. Unfortunately, we have to implement the spec. If we think it is wrong we can ask the EG for a clarification but in the mean time we should be compliant. > Th

Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-19 Thread Konstantin Kolinko
2008/9/19 Mark Thomas <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Mark Thomas wrote: >> Konstantin Kolinko wrote: >>> In JSP 2.1 spec there is chapter >>> JSP.1.6 Quoting and Escape Conventions >>> - see "Quoting in Attributes" part there. >>> >>> Thus, IMHO, ${\'string literal\'} will be valid if used as the value for

Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-19 Thread Mark Thomas
Mark Thomas wrote: > Konstantin Kolinko wrote: >> In JSP 2.1 spec there is chapter >> JSP.1.6 Quoting and Escape Conventions >> - see "Quoting in Attributes" part there. >> >> Thus, IMHO, ${\'string literal\'} will be valid if used as the value for >> an attribute of custom tag. I've looked at this

Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-19 Thread Remy Maucherat
On Fri, 2008-09-19 at 12:45 +0100, Mark Thomas wrote: > Tags are involved so it looks like this is a bug in Tomcat rather than the > TCK. Maybe a regression from my fix for 45427? It might just be me but > anything in Jasper to do with EL seems really fragile. I am not aware of this failure, so it

Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-19 Thread Mark Thomas
Konstantin Kolinko wrote: > In JSP 2.1 spec there is chapter > JSP.1.6 Quoting and Escape Conventions > - see "Quoting in Attributes" part there. > > Thus, IMHO, ${\'string literal\'} will be valid if used as the value for > an attribute of custom tag. > > The example from the spec > "/> > become

Re: EL and TCK

2008-09-19 Thread Konstantin Kolinko
2008/9/19 Mark Thomas <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > With the recent fixes to the EL code it appears that there is a bug in the > TCK. I won't repeat the exact test since the TCK licence won't let me do > that but a simple version is that the TCK thinks the following expression > should be valid: > > ${\'s

EL and TCK

2008-09-18 Thread Mark Thomas
With the recent fixes to the EL code it appears that there is a bug in the TCK. I won't repeat the exact test since the TCK licence won't let me do that but a simple version is that the TCK thinks the following expression should be valid: ${\'string literal\'} For those of you with access to the