Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-15 Thread Joel Bernstein
I'm quite excited about the vector search as well. This has a lot of interesting scientific and machine learning applications, for example large scale multi-variate knn regression. I'll start testing out the PR next week. Joel Bernstein http://joelsolr.blogspot.com/ On Fri, Jan 14, 2022 at 12:

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-15 Thread Alessandro Benedetti
I perfectly agree, I can give another cleanup next week before the merge, but I am not entirely sure I can avoid to touch at all some of those monster classes. Maybe we need another line of work, as we were discussing before, to make in general Solr more modular. I'll be at the committer meetup a

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread Jan Høydahl
Good points. Yea, changes could be generated from JIRA with releasedocmaker from Yetus, although it is not perfect either. It would be less worrying to add new things only to main such as neural search, if such a feature could be added to Solr either as a contrib module / package or at least as

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread David Smiley
I like letting features bake in main & 9x! I don't plan to merge anything to 9.0 until after the committer meeting, and then will do a dev list follow-up so anyone can weigh in if they didn't attend. Two problems: (1) CHANGES.txt management has always been a pain (IMO) and it could be here especia

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread Jan Høydahl
Thanks for being so structured and transparent about your proposals, David. I'll not comment on each JIRA here but reply to your "approval" question. As RM my primary concern is to see to that the release happens, in due time, with good quality and with no last-minute changes that causes instabi

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread Jan Høydahl
Just go ahead with neural in main and branch_9x, and put it on the agenda for the committers meeting. Will you attend? Jan Høydahl > 14. jan. 2022 kl. 18:56 skrev Alessandro Benedetti : > >  > Sorry David, I didn't mean to abruptly raid the topic, I misread it was just > the lists of your own

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread Alessandro Benedetti
Sorry David, I didn't mean to abruptly raid the topic, I misread it was just the lists of your own proposals :) -- Alessandro Benedetti Apache Lucene/Solr PMC member and Committer Director, R&D Software Engineer, Search Consultant www.sease.io On Fri, 14 Jan 2022 at 17:52

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread Alessandro Benedetti
No problem from my side! I am having Cassandra review the doc on the weekend. I'll leave another week for late reviewers/ anyone that wants to raise any objections/insights and I'll proceed with the merge the week following! -- Alessandro Benedetti Apache Lucene/Solr PMC me

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread David Smiley
I was merely listing PRs I was working on or closely related to; not an exclusive list to those others are working on :-) ~ David Smiley Apache Lucene/Solr Search Developer http://www.linkedin.com/in/davidwsmiley On Fri, Jan 14, 2022 at 12:45 PM Ishan Chattopadhyaya < ichattopadhy...@gmail.com>

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread Ishan Chattopadhyaya
Hi Alessandro, I'd strongly appreciate if this can be included in 9.0. It is a very thorough work and clearly the best highlight of 9.0, if you're able to include it.Thanks for your work. Regards, Ishan On Fri, 14 Jan, 2022, 10:59 pm Alessandro Benedetti, wrote: > What about the Neural Search co

Re: Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-14 Thread Alessandro Benedetti
What about the Neural Search contribution I am working on: https://github.com/apache/solr/pull/476 ? It's pretty much done and low risk (just waiting for some additional review, but I hope I fixed most of the concerns found so far). To me, it could easily be on 9.1 but the fact that is completed co

Some 9.0 proposals of mine

2022-01-13 Thread David Smiley
The following changes are on my mind for 9.0, and some others. I will do many; others I'm a reviewer for a contributor. I think these are best done on a major release, but this isn't to say each is "important". Jan (as RM), please let me know what you think. I suppose I need your approval? Obse