Re: Solr partial shutdown problem

2022-01-24 Thread Jan Høydahl
Such a big change in behavior is best done in major release. It’s not a bit problem for systems like k8s that use liveness probes. But for normal installs and for plain Docker installs it would be a benefit if the jvm process simply exits on fatal error, so the daemon process need not be as adva

Re: Solr partial shutdown problem

2022-01-24 Thread Mike Drob
Is this a 9.0 blocker? Seems like any APIs we change would be internal only? On Mon, Jan 24, 2022 at 9:26 AM Jan Høydahl wrote: > Hi, > > Solr runs in a servlet container (Jetty), and normally you want one webapp > to not be able to cause issues for another one by e.g. running > System.exit(). >

Solr partial shutdown problem

2022-01-24 Thread Jan Høydahl
Hi, Solr runs in a servlet container (Jetty), and normally you want one webapp to not be able to cause issues for another one by e.g. running System.exit(). But Solr is different, it is the only servlet in the container, and in certain cases (such as syntax error in config files during startup),