Re: SolrCloudManager... DistribStateManager...

2023-06-26 Thread David Smiley
Gus, what do you mean by "local management"? Anyway, I think I was misunderstood. And besides, admittedly you two aren't familiar with the classes in question. But here goes a clarification: I'm concerned about internal SolrCloud code design/maintenance with respect to these abstractions -- som

Re: SolrCloudManager... DistribStateManager...

2023-06-26 Thread Gus Heck
Yeah, looking back at the original email I read too quick and misunderstood the juxtaposition of "manager" and "extracting", but the current effort to make embedded zk a supported production config (not sure where that stands), and some form of or tweak to server roles stuff would get us through

Re: SolrCloudManager... DistribStateManager...

2023-06-26 Thread Eric Pugh
I dropped the notes that Gus made into a Miro board just to visualize it.. https://miro.com/app/board/o9J_lm8BmXE=/?moveToWidget=3458764558006503531&cot=14 Be interesting during one of our community calls to talk about “what do we have” and “what are we missing?”…. Feels to me like a numbe

Re: SolrCloudManager... DistribStateManager...

2023-06-20 Thread Eric Pugh
I think this is a very interesting progression…..It’s a really nice mental model of “what tools should I reach for when?" > On Jun 20, 2023, at 11:41 AM, Gus Heck wrote: > > I'm not familiar with these classes, but I'm not particularly fond of > anything that leads us in a direction of requ

Re: SolrCloudManager... DistribStateManager...

2023-06-20 Thread Gus Heck
I'm not familiar with these classes, but I'm not particularly fond of anything that leads us in a direction of requiring a *third* installation for initial use. (Zookeeper being #2 already). That said, we really need a good replacement for autoscaling, and large installs might reasonably want to of