Re: [DISCUSS] Deprecating Result Grouping

2025-01-11 Thread David Smiley
Indeed, Result Grouping supports distributed search. I see this documented in its ref guide page (at the bottom), and also tested -- TestDistributedGrouping. I wish Result Grouping functionality was better separated. I suppose QueryComponent isn't *too* bad, because of the method based organizat

Re: [DISCUSS] Deprecating Result Grouping

2025-01-10 Thread Alessandro Benedetti
It's been a while since I don't check that, @jason do you mean that: 1) results grouping happens after shard aggregations 2) field collapsing happens before shard aggregations Literally shooting in the dark, just reading the email, with zero time to investigate, but in general, I'm in favour of de

Re: [DISCUSS] Deprecating Result Grouping

2025-01-10 Thread Jason Gerlowski
I'm not against deprecating "Result Grouping" per-se, but it has one huge advantage over Collapse/Expand: Result Grouping is the only approach that supports multi-shard. Should we come up with a plan for that and other gaps before we deprecate Result Grouping? Deprecating the feature before there

[DISCUSS] Deprecating Result Grouping

2025-01-09 Thread David Smiley
Solr has supported Result Grouping[1] for a long time but has mostly been duplicative with Collapse & Expand[2]. At the start of the RG docs, there's this notice which I wrote many (10?) years ago: > Prefer Collapse & Expand instead > Solr’s Collapse and Expand Results feature is newer and mostly