Re: [DISCUSS] SIP-24 Java Security Manager replacement

2025-06-05 Thread Houston Putman
Sorry for the late reply, been vacationing and busy! Thanks for getting this going Jan. This is a great SIP. I've put a good amount of thought into this, especially: >- Limit what file paths can be read/written > > And I don't think it's an easy thing to solve, but something we certainly ne

Re: [DISCUSS] SIP-24 Java Security Manager replacement

2025-06-05 Thread David Smiley
> I know you have under "Rejected Alternatives" the statement "Leaving Solr unprotected", but honestly, I think that is just too broad of a statement. I completely agree; that felt wrong when I read that. The SecurityManager is not Solr's front-line protection mechanism -- that's authentication

Re: [DISCUSS] SIP-24 Java Security Manager replacement

2025-06-05 Thread David Eric Pugh
Ten is the perfect time to rip it out.   Let's separate ripping it out from "whatever else we decide"... Otherwise we'll bike shed it to death! I know you have under "Rejected Alternatives" the statement "Leaving Solr unprotected", but honestly, I think that is just too broad of a statement.