Re: What I want for Solr 10...

2024-12-21 Thread Arrieta, Alejandro
Hi, As we are making requests to Solr Santa for Solr 10, I have mine: -What is your guestimate for the Solr 10 release? Currently, only one Solr version is supported: https://solr.apache.org/news.html#solr-8-reaches-end-of-life And because writing content directly for 10 may be a better use o

Re: [DISCUSS] Time to thank HDFS module for it's service and remove it?

2024-12-21 Thread Arrieta, Alejandro
Hi, I read both dev and user lists every day in lurker mode, and yes, I read the Hadoop auth mail threads. But I am too low on the food chain pyramid, like bottom level, lol :-) I mentioned this mail list thread in the internal appropriate chat room. 2 comments: 1) Most generally, final users of

Re: [DISCUSS] Time to thank HDFS module for it's service and remove it?

2024-12-21 Thread David Smiley
+1 to LinkedIn. As I said, let's see if they even notice without you finding a POC to tell them. At least for a month, if you don't mind :-) I'm really curious if we hear from them. On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 11:13 AM David Eric Pugh wrote: > > I will drop an email to the user list in January wh

Re: [DISCUSS] Time to thank HDFS module for it's service and remove it?

2024-12-21 Thread David Eric Pugh
I will drop an email to the user list in January when folks are back to get some feedback.   I will check my LinkedIn and see who I know that is involved in the Hadoop project and the companies that supported it and see if that shakes some feedback loose.   In a perfect world, if we had some

Re: [DISCUSS] Time to thank HDFS module for it's service and remove it?

2024-12-21 Thread David Smiley
Any such proposal should start with an attempt to solicit user input. I do wonder if we are doing enough to communicate important decisions like this to our users (to solicit this feedback). I worded that poorly maybe; I don't mean to suggest inadequacy on us necessarily as I have a greater conce

Re: What I want for Solr 10...

2024-12-21 Thread David Eric Pugh
I'd like to keep the simplicity of the extraction module, but without the in process aspect that it has today.   I can imagine some interesting use cases of the extraction module plus the new LLM module plus some streaming to build all my vectors inside my Solr ecosystem. On Friday, De

[DISCUSS] Time to thank HDFS module for it's service and remove it?

2024-12-21 Thread David Eric Pugh
Should we remove the hdfs module from Solr 10?   Inspired by some of the discussions in https://lists.apache.org/thread/lltc0wjdghq18tt37zlrsd8ty35qsytl around removing the hadoop-auth module, I think that this is a real possiblity. I found some earlier work in https://issues.apache.org/jira/brow